
IBM’s aptly-titled 2011 Commuter Pain Study polled drivers around the planet to find whose life sucks the most behind the wheel, based on the following factors:
1) Commuting time
2) Time stuck in traffic, agreement that:
3) Price of gas is already too high
4) Traffic has gotten worse
5) Start/stop traffic is a problem
6) Driving causes stress
7) Driving causes anger
8) Traffic affects work
9) Traffic so bad driving stopped and
10) Decided not to make trip due to traffic.
The results might surprise you, unless you live in Mexico City, whose traffic is appallingly three times as bad as New York’s. Mexico City napped the #1 worst spot, with China claiming the next two, rounding out the three worst cities to operate a motor vehicle. The total list, ranked by worst to best of cities polled, is as follows:
Mexico City: 108
Shenzhen: 95
Beijing: 95
Nairobi: 88
Johannesburg: 83
Bangalore: 75
New Delhi: 72
Moscow: 65
Milan: 53
Singapore: 44
Buenos Aires: 42
Los Angeles: 34
Paris: 31
Madrid: 28
New York City: 28
Toronto: 27
Stockholm: 26
Chicago: 25
London: 23
Montreal: 21
But this isn’t just an exercise in schadenfreude (although it can certainly be used for that)! Rather, IBM thinks the sort of data should prompt us to actually do something about it — because it’s actually hurting our brains:
12 of the 15 cities surveyed in both 2010 and 2011 reported year-over-year increases in respondents who said that roadway traffic has increased their stress levels, with several cities posting substantial increases. For example, New York (45% in 2011 vs. 13% in 2010), Los Angeles (44% in 2011 vs. 21% in 2010), Toronto (40% in 2011 vs. 14% in 2010), London (33% in 2011 vs. 19% in 2010), Milan (61% in 2011 vs. 38% in 2010), and Johannesburg (52% in 2011 vs. 30% in 2010).
So how do we fix gridlock? IBM says building more (or wider) roads won’t help — not enough space or money. The answer lies in data. Which makes sense, as IBM makes money by processing and selling data. But it does make sense — taking the roads we have already and routing traffic through them more efficiently. This means collecting data via road sensors and vehicle GPS, and sending it to drivers and municipalities in a way that lets you avoid congestion. That might mean taking an earlier or later exit. It might mean staying at work 20 minutes later, or leaving 15 minutes earlier.
These slight adjustments could make an enormous difference, because IBM wants this data to be way more than realtime — real time doesn’t cut it. Traffic data has to predict the roads, day after day. Once computers can tell us how bad cars are going to behave before they even do it, we can work backwards and correct problems before they arrive. It’s a pretty science fiction take on the daily commute, but predicting the future might be the surest way of keeping you from taking that baseball bat out of your trunk. [IBM]


















EckyThump
Friday, September 9, 2011 at 7:43 AMMeh, Toowoomba should be on there somewhere, Drivers here are the most belligerent and poorly trained I’ve seen anywhere in OZ! #]
Dave
Friday, September 9, 2011 at 8:22 AMbecause the RTA doesn’t require licences for a Horse and Cart. :P
olearymo
Friday, September 9, 2011 at 8:47 AMWhoa, whoa, wait up there Dave. There are CARTS now?
olearymo
Friday, September 9, 2011 at 8:46 AMYou just beat me, I was gonna make a Toowoomba reference!
D
Friday, September 9, 2011 at 8:48 AMhmmm seem fine compare to Brisbane
Terry
Monday, September 12, 2011 at 3:28 PMyeah, they guy carrying the results from a Brisbane survey is still stuck in traffic.
Didn’t get it to the publishers in time.
Hale street anyone?
Vincent
Friday, September 9, 2011 at 5:30 PMYeah right… For having lived in Paris, Singapore and Jakarta, I can tell you this study is BS.
For one, there is no way that Paris fares better than Singapore. No way in the world.
Second, where the hell is Jakarta on the list? This is the worst place I’ve been to and it’s definitely much worse than Singapore and Paris.
Jubbin
Friday, September 9, 2011 at 6:29 PMThats because Singapore is a tiny island therefore traffic is there by default. Secondly gas/petrol isn’t that expensive in Singapore as compared to say Paris.
Finally – 10) Decided not to make trip due to traffic. No.. Singapore has traffic because people still decide to make the trip.
As for Jakarta, I haven’t been there in 18 years so I can’t say what it is now.
Joe Wong
Saturday, September 10, 2011 at 9:36 AMno Bangkok? no Sydney?