Hurricane Sandy Could Really Flood The New York Subway System

First it was Nicole. Then it was Irene. New York dodged a major bullet when those two storms missed the mark. Its massive, essential subway system survived unscathed.

But now New York City is really flooding, and unless a miracle happens in the next few hours, NOAA says this will be "widespread damaging storm, possibly of historic proportions". Perhaps the biggest ever in the region. This could be the storm that kills the New York subway system.

According to a report by the Wall Street Journal, MTA Chairman Joseph Lhota has declared that he thinks "Monday and Tuesday are going to be difficult days". Lhota believes that by "Wednesday [the MTA] should have service, but whether it's a full complement of service, it'd be very difficult for [him] to say now." Like everyone else, he admitted that "he doesn't know "when this event will end and when the power issues will be corrected".

However, NOAA tells another story. They say that this is the possibly the largest storm to ever hit the area, with "widespread power outages and significant flooding".

New York is Flooding Now

Indeed, parts of New York City are already flooding -- and the storm isn't over the city in full force yet. That doesn't happen until around 4pm local time today (7am AEDT). Take a look at these images, just taken a few minutes ago:

"The Hudson River has breached its banks 8.53am" by Nigel Barker.

"East River rises above last two steps of Get Down, and approaches 3rd, at end of Wall Street" by Arturas Rosenbacher.

"Here we are marooned in Red Hook, Brooklyn!!" by Greenpainting.

How the Subway Can Collapse and Flood

Most people may not realise it -- or never have occasion to think about it -- but NYC's subway system is susceptible to flooding. The possibility is quite real.

What most people don't know is that we depend on just 700 fragile water pumps to keep the tunnels dry -- some a century old.

In fact, if someone powered down all these pumps tomorrow, the entire subway network would be inundated in just a few hours. To give you an idea of how complex and massive this system is, it pulls 50 million litres of water out of the subway on any sunny day. No rain. Not even a single drop of water from the sky. If Sandy manages to kill the power or any of the fragile old pumps protecting the system, there may be some serious problems.

On a rainy day, the pump system is absolute chaos, to the point where the MTA -- NYC's Metropolitan Transportation Authority -- lives in permanent panic, fearing events like Sandy, the hurricane system that is approaching the little town right now. "At some point, it would be too much to handle," said the head of the hydraulics team back in 2006, Peter Velasquez Jr, "you've got rain plus wind. It basically would shut down the system. You hope not. You pray that it doesn't.

"To give you an idea about how bad this could be, some of the oldest pumps in the NYCTA system were bought second-hand from the builders of the Panama Canal. I worked for the TA many years ago and even then the pumps were considered a serious problem. The Panama Canal was finished in 1914."

This means that NYC's hydraulic team -- less than two hundred people -- are now on full alert, ready to intervene and install additional portable water pumps in whatever stations are needed. This is not an easy task. When the water reaches a certain level it touches the third rail, which carries 625 volts. That makes the water extremely dangerous for these workers.

It's happened recently

Back in the 1990s, a water main broke open, completely flooding the station at 125th Street and St Nicholas Avenue. They had to send scuba divers to fix it, and use a diesel-powered train car to take the water out. It took an entire week to drain the station, extracting 10,000 litres per minute. That's more than 100 million litres.

But you don't need to fully inundate the tunnels to take the subway system out. The water flooding could take out entire lines if the pumps fail to keep the levels below their safety limits. In 2004, the subway system stopped after Hurricane Frances spewed two inches of rain per hour over the city. In 2007, the system shut down again. At that time Governor Eliot Spitzer declared that "the cause of the cascading outages across the mass transportation system this morning was the inability of our drainage system to handle what was, we believe, three inches of rain within a one-hour period."

Not much has changed since then. The MTA's drainage system still can only slurp 1.5 inches of rain per hour, which is much, much less than what Sandy is bringing. It sounds like Velasquez's scenario: You hope not. You pray that it doesn't.

Photo of diver by Littlesam/Shutterstock



    I am an Australian on holiday in New York for just over a week. Unfortunately we have coincided with Hurricane Sandy. Make no mistake, it is totally crazy outside with wind and rain, and all the tunnels and public transport systems have been shutdown. Its crazy.

    Go to the New York state library, burn books to stay warm and wait for Dennis Quaid to arrive.

      You still have 2 days before you need to resort to that...

    this is crazy...good luck and best wishes to all the new yorkers going through this at the moment!

    Surely they can turn off the power to the live rail?
    It's not like they'll have trains running!

      I'm calling BS on the third rail 'electrifying' the water. There's this concept called "turning off the power".

      What if the 3rd rail is what keeps the pumps going too? Meaning the pumps are connected to 3rd rail

    is any body else concerned that one of the largest cities in the world hasnt upgraded part of its key infrastructures in 100 years?

      America general

        The world in general.

        A) If it aint broke... don't fix it
        B) Politicians are only in power for a few years, so short term they reap no benefits... but end up spending money (which will be used against them in their next election) and the next guy is going to get the credit when it all goes well.

      they've been focused on other things. like war.

      Yeah - whenever I go to the states, I always feel like you can tell exactly when Reagan was elected, because that was the last time public infrastructure was built/maintained.

    So in the 90's It failed, In 2004 it was pushed past its limits and in 2007 it was pushed to double what it can handle. Still lets not bother upgrading our 100 year old pumps. With new ones that probably use less power to do a better job.

    So when is someone going to use stuxnet to turn off the subway pumps?

      hahah you'd have to have pumps that weren't running on steam engines and coal to do that with! lol seriously, 1914!?!?!?!

Join the discussion!