In a meta-twist worthy of Deadpool himself, the plot of the upcoming Once Upon a Deadpool may not have come from star Ryan Reynolds or his Deadpool 2 co-writers Rhett Reese and Paul Wernick. It may have come from a seemingly random tweet dated December 2017. That’s when New York-based writer and artist Michael Vincent Bramley posted the following:
@VancityReynolds If Marvel forces you to make a PG-13 Deadpool, just copy the framing device from The Princess Bride and have Deadpool censoring it for Fred Savage as a bedtime story. A kidnapped adult Fred Savage. There, I fixed it.— M.V.B. (@MVBramley) December 7, 2017
The tweet came shortly after news broke that Disney was considering acquiring 20th Century Fox, which sparked all kinds of speculation about Fox’s Marvel characters teaming up with Disney’s, and how the enthusiastically R-rated Deadpool would be handled. “I was thinking that there had to be a fun in-universe way to do the same Deadpool without the swearing and ultra violence,” Bramley told io9 via email. “Then I thought about The Princess Bride’s framing device being about censorship (and, of course, Deadpool would be a fan) and the idea of Deadpool kidnapping an adult Fred Savage and forcing him to listen to Deadpool read the movie kind of cracked me up.”
Bramley tweeted about the idea and went about his life. Then, earlier this week, he was at a mall in Michigan with his wife (hoping to find Detective Pikachu merchandise, if you can believe it) when she asked him if he’d seen the trailer for the new Deadpool.
“She said it was a PG cut and that the trailer was great,” Bramley said. “I told her I had the best PG work-around for Deadpool ever and explained the Fred Savage pitch. I gave the kidnapped Fred Savage spiel and, because she couldn’t remember it from a year ago, she assumed I was just describing the trailer. It quickly dawned on us that something was up and I started to freak out a bit, because I remembered tweeting it at Ryan Reynolds and I usually never check Twitter. I actually barely tweet at all. Usually I share these thoughts on Facebook, but I guess I thought that idea was a bit too perfect and they might actually use it.”
Bramley has since provided the proof in the form of the above tweet and even a more detailed Facebook post.
Sooo… I tweeted the exact plot of the new 'Once Upon A Deadpool' PG version of #Deadpool2 at Ryan Reynolds almost a year ago and it somehow wound up in a movie without me knowing. #deadpool #ryanreynolds #xmen #movies #OnceUponADeadpool #fredsavage #marvelmovies #mcu pic.twitter.com/tTMHwh2A1a— M.V.B. (@MVBramley) November 21, 2018
We don’t know when specifically Reynolds and his Deadpool 2 co-writers Rhett Reese and Paul Wernick had the idea for Once Upon a Deadpool, but talking to Slashfilm recently, Wernick recalled that Reynolds came up with it.
“After Deadpool 2 came out and we were all sitting around, we came to it less about the idea of let’s make a PG-13 movie and more, ‘Let’s talk a little bit about Deadpool,’” Wernick said. “We were kicking around some ideas and then I think it was Ryan [Reynolds] who had the great framing device and we all got excited and went to the studio.”
In that interview, Wernick implied the conversation happened relatively close to when filming of the Fred Savage scenes took place, and roughly puts that in the time frame of July/August 2018. (He says it happened about two months before the interview took place in October.) All of which suggests that the idea for Once Upon a Deadpool came well after Bramley’s tweet in December 2017.
“I mean…maybe [Ryan Reynolds] had the idea first, but it’s fucking eerie how I didn’t get a single detail wrong in my summary,” Bramley tweeted. “Plagiarism? I hope not. I fuckin’ love Ryan Reynolds. Cryptomnesia maybe? Can I at least get some premiere tickets please?”
We’ve reached out to 20th Century Fox, as well as representatives for Reynolds, Wernick, and Reese, and have yet to hear back as of publication.
What happens next is a mystery. Bramley, of course, doesn’t own the IPs for Deadpool or The Princess Bride, so even if he did come up with the idea, you’d think it might be hard to have any kind of legal case. (This is why directors can’t accept unsolicited screenplays, by the way.) He also told us he doesn’t think suing Disney seems like a very good idea.
But, here’s an even crazier idea. What if Bramley, himself a talented artist and comic book writer, is in cahoots with the Once Upon a Deadpool team and this whole thing is just an elaborate publicity stunt? Bramley’s first post on Instgaram was in May of last year, probably around when this idea started to percolate, and—it just so happens—features Domino from Deadpool 2, whom he refers to as “his new favourite mutant.” Plus, all of his other comic art on that page is from Fox-owned Marvel properties. It’s curious, to say the least.
Also, we know that the Deadpool 2 team likes to have fun with its social media marketing. Who can forget the Twitter page of everyone’s favourite X-Force member, Peter?
“I mean…It’s not a ruse,” Bramley told us when asked about this. “I wish it were. If Ryan Reynolds wants me to say it’s a ruse, I’ll say it’s a ruse. In return I’d only ask that he purchase us some matching ‘BFF’ bracelets and wear his in interviews or cell phone app ads, or whatever he’s doing next. “
Either way, the whole thing is an interesting twist on an already twisted Hollywood idea.
For more, make sure you’re following us on our new Instagram @io9dotcom.