A federal jury in Texas has ordered Apple to pay out $US502.6 million ($648.3 million) to VirtnetX Holding Corp., the kind of company often referred to as a patent troll, in the eighth year of contentious legal battles between the two companies, Bloomberg reported today.
Apple’s senior vice president of worldwide product marketing, Phil Schiller, highlights iPhone 6 messaging features at a 2014 event in Cupertino, California. Photo: AP
According to Bloomberg, VirnetX’s stock skyrocketed by 44 per cent today after the jury concluded Apple was violating its patents on secure communications technology. Apple stock was barely affected, if at was all, given the tech giant rolls in hundreds of billions of dollars in revenue per year. Per Bloomberg, this court battle has been raging for some time, though VirnetX could ultimately end up seeing little to none of the money:
VirnetX claimed that Apple’s FaceTime, VPN on Demand and iMessage features infringe four patents related to secure communications, claims that Apple denied.
The dispute has bounced between the district court, patent office and Federal Circuit since 2010. There have been multiple trials, most recently one involving earlier versions of the Apple devices. A jury in that case awarded $302 million [$AU390 million] that a judge later increased to $439.7 million [$AU567 million].
For VirnetX, the jury verdict in its favour could be a short-lived victory. The Patent Trial and Appeal Board has said the patents are invalid, in cases that are currently before the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington.
As Ars Technica detailed last year, VirnetX is a publicly-traded company that does offer some products, including a “secure mail and messaging system called the Gabriel Collaboration Suite”, though SEC filings show they derive the entirety of their revenue from judgements in patent lawsuits. Per The Verge, the East Texas district was considered one of the most fertile court systems to pursue such cases, which have a higher chance of being thrown out elsewhere. But the US Supreme Court ruled in 2017 that patent holders can no longer just choose where to file suit – bad news for the Texas city of Marshall, where an astonishing 25 per cent of all US patent litigation was filed.
VirnetX has previously pulled off this trick before, extracting $US200 million ($258 million) from Microsoft in 2010 and later $US23 million ($30 million) for updated products, according to Bloomberg.