Apple CEO Tim Cook, whose company mostly sells consumer products, has largely avoided being sucked into the rapidly-expanding scandal over the alleged Russian effort to promote internal division in the US before the 2016 US elections – unlike other tech giants such as Google, Twitter and Facebook, all of which now admit some degree of involvement. With his hands washed of this particular matter, Cook is taking some shots at them.
In an interview with NBC’s Lester Holt earlier this week, Cook argued that the problem isn’t limited to Russian efforts, but social media and other platforms’ hands-off approach to combating misinformation and propaganda.
“I don’t believe the big issue are ads from foreign governments,” Cook told Holt. “I believe that’s like .1 per cent of the issue.”
— NBC Nightly News with Lester Holt (@NBCNightlyNews) November 1, 2017
“The bigger issue is that some of these tools are used to divide people, to manipulate people, to get fake news to people in broad numbers so as to influence their thinking,” Cook continued. “This to me is the No. 1 through 10 issue.”
Cook added that social media companies have “learned along the way a lot” since 2016, but he warned them that amid congressional hearings into the matter, lofty rhetoric about disruption and the supposedly progressive nature of technology just won’t cut it.
“We’ll probably learn more in those hearings as to the particulars,” Cook said. “But I do think that technology itself doesn’t want to be good. It doesn’t want to be anything. It’s up to the creator of the technology and the user of the technology to make it good.”
Cook, whose company has not always had a great track record on being “good”, then immediately undercut his point about tech companies’ lack of social responsibility by urging Congress to slash corporate tax rates – in a manner hard to interpret as anything other than encouraging further deference to massive international corporations.
“The biggest issue for corporations in this country is if you earn money outside the United States, which most companies increasingly will,” Cook said. “It’s taxed in those countries, by the way, the only way you can bring it into the US and invest, is if you pay 40 per cent, for us.”
“This is kind of a crazy thing to do,” he added. “So what do people do? They don’t bring it to the United States. It’s not good for investment in the US. And so this needs to be fixed. In my view, it should have been fixed years ago. But let’s get it done now.”
As Business Insider noted, Apple has a $US261.5 billion ($339 billion) stash of cash and marketable securities socked away, approximately 94 per cent of it overseas – and Cook is essentially suggesting that little of it will come back unless he gets a sweetheart tax deal. Congressional Republicans are currently mulling one of the biggest tax slashes in history. President Donald Trump reportedly wants to call it the “Cut Cut Cut Act”, while researchers from Trump’s alma mater Wharton say it will explode the deficit. It sure seems like Cook is putting his finger on the scale in favour of a fairly radical redefinition of who is supposed to pay for what.
It’s a pretty strange vision of social responsibility in tech that laments how the industry promotes political division while sitting on a hoard of cash during a time of skyrocketing income inequality, but hey, welcome to 2017.