Aussie Scientists And Experts React To Today's Massive Gravitational Wave Discovery

Image: CSIRO

Overnight, scientists announced a significant discovery: the first detection of gravitational waves during a pair of neutron stars colliding and forming a black hole. This opens up a huge swathe of new research in astronomy, and Australian scientists -- including those that took part in the event -- are understandably excited.

AU Editor's Note: These expert reactions come to us courtesy of the Australian Science Media Centre, and are republished here in full. Since this is a pretty significant announcement, we're sharing the full comments from Australian scientists rather than editing them. -- Cam

Professor Matthew Bailes, director of the ARC Centre of Excellence for Gravitational Waves and at Swinburne University of Technology

"This was the first time that any cosmic event was observed through both light it emitted and the gravitational ripples it caused in the fabric of space-time.

"Never before have we seen where in the universe gravitational waves came from; the subsequent avalanche of science was virtually unparalleled in modern astrophysics."

Dr Eric Howell, ARC DECRA Fellow in the School of Physics and Astrophysics, University of Western Australia

"The gravitational wave observations of black-hole collisions by the LIGO and Virgo detectors has been an incredible feat in technology and has accelerated our knowledge of the extreme and dynamic universe. However, on August 17th “colliding neutron stars invited themselves to the gravitational wave party and announced their presence with authority”.

"We had not expected to detect such an event so close; as a result it was very loud. To be accompanied by a gamma-ray burst was incredible. The association between this type of short duration gamma-ray burst and neutron star collisions had been predicted for around 30 years. It is now confirmed. Thousands of gamma-ray bursts have been recorded, but this was the closest of this type ever observed. Much is unknown about these bursts and given previous understanding, this event simply should not have happened."

Winthrop Professor David Blair, node director at the ARC Centre of Excellence for Gravitational Wave Discovery and at the School of Physics, University of Western Australia

"I started working on the first high sensitivity gravitational wave detectors in the USA in 1973. I expected to spend a year or two detecting Einstein’s waves and then move on to something else.

"We pinned our hopes on gravitational waves from neutron stars. This was our holy grail but it eluded us even when gravity waves from black holes had been detected. Forty four years later we have found the holy grail!

"It is astonishing that a single very faint signal lasting a minute combined with an even briefer burst of gamma rays and a fading glow of light, can reveal so much: the scale of the universe, the speed of gravitational waves, the mechanism of gamma ray bursts, and the origin of gold."

Professor Susan Scott, chief investigator from the Research School of Physics and Engineering at The Australian National University

"Neutron stars are the densest stars in the universe. The astronomers have found many of them, alone but also in pairs orbiting each other. As they circle each other they radiate gravitational waves and their orbit shrinks. We knew that eventually many of them must smash together in violent collisions but we had never seen it happen. The astronomers simply did not know where to point their telescopes at the right time.

"The LIGO and Virgo gravitational wave observatories can’t be pointed to a place on the sky, they just sit there and wait for something 'big' to happen in the Universe. And on 17 August this year something really big happened - a gravitational wave swept into our detectors which was the hallmark signal of two neutron stars colliding. It was our closest source and our strongest signal of our five detections announced so far.

"We quickly sent details of a patch of sky to astronomy partners all over the world. What followed was an unprecedented avalanche of telescopes and satellites scrambling to scan this patch to pinpoint the source and image it with light, x-rays, radio and gamma rays. The age of multi-messenger astronomy had truly begun."

AusSMC note: Susan states no conflicts of interest, but says she is a member of the LIGO Scientific Collaboration.

Dr Paul Lasky is a Lecturer and Future Fellow at the Monash Centre for Astrophysics, Monash University

"It is fair to say that this is one of the biggest astronomical discoveries of the century so far. In 2015 we made the first detection of gravitational waves which came from two massive black holes. This meant that only the gravitational waves were detected, but traditional telescopes saw nothing.

"This time we managed to catch the collision of two neutron stars — dead stellar remnants that weigh more than our Sun but are just 10 kilometers across. When these neutron stars merged they created a huge explosion which was seen using gamma-ray telescopes two seconds after the collision as seen by the gravitational-wave detectors.

"Over the subsequent hours, days and weeks we saw this event across all different types of light, including x-rays, ultraviolet, optical and radio. The amount of physics that is being learned from this one collision is truly immense. This is a watershed moment in astrophysics, and brings us into the era of ‘multimessenger’ astronomy."

AusSMC note: Paul is part of the LIGO Scientific Collaboration, and has been actively working on the science that is to be announced on Tuesday morning. He is also an Associate Investigator of OzGrav.

Associate Professor Jeff Cooke, ARC Future Fellow at the Centre for Astrophysics & Supercomputing, Swinburne University of Technology

"On August 17, the LIGO and Virgo gravitational wave detectors recorded two neutron stars, for the first time, merging about 130 million light years away (one light year is about 10 trillion kilometres). However, this distance is 'very close' in astronomical terms and is essentially in our ‘back yard’. As such, it gave us a great view of the event. Although an event like this was predicted to be detected (eventually) by the very sensitive LIGO/Virgo detectors, no one expected it to occur so soon. Mainly because it's a very difficult detection and would have to occur very close, which would be very rare.

"Gravitational wave detectors can detect black holes and neutron stars merging, but cannot locate them with great accuracy. As such, we don’t know exactly where in the vast universe they occur or, specifically, in which galaxy they occur. Until now, only black hole mergers have been detected and they do not produce light, so we have no way to locate them precisely or study them with our telescopes. Neutron star mergers do produce light and, as such, we can pinpoint where they are and study them in great detail. This was the first time astronomers can accurately locate a gravitational wave event and observe it in detail with telescopes.

"About two seconds after the gravitational wave detection, a telescope in space (Fermi) detected a burst of gamma-rays. Astronomers suspected that this burst and the gravitational wave event were connected. For about 50 years, it had been theorised that highly energetic gamma-rays of light would occur when two neutron stars merge. The later confirmation of this connection solved a 50 year-old mystery.

"Because the light was seen at the same time as the gravitational waves, we can confirm that gravitational waves travel at the speed of light through the universe.

"Alerts of the gravitational wave event and the gamma-ray burst were sent out to teams of astronomers worldwide that had been preparing years for this. Astronomers worldwide dropped what they were doing to turn their telescopes to this event. We discovered a bright explosion called a kilonova (named so, because they are about 1000 (kilo) times brighter than a nova). Such explosions have been theorised to accompany neutron star mergers but have never been observed. With these observations, we witnessed a kilonova for the first time, confirming the theory, and we now understand how they work.

"Astronomers stayed with the event, because it was expected to fade away forever, several days later. The event was observed with every type of telescope at every wavelength of light. It was identified and located in a galaxy named NGC 4993 that is located near our Milky Way galaxy and in the Southern Hemisphere of our night sky. We observed an explosion, a kilonova, unfold in front of our eyes, more beautifully than ever imagined. Kilonovae produce the heaviest elements around us today. The event enabled us to see where, and how, exotic elements such as gold, platinum, and uranium are formed.

"Knowing the distance and the strength of the event, we now have another means to measure the expansion rate of the universe and its age.

"Finally, the location of the event was a bit troublesome. It was in a direction in the sky near the Sun. This made things difficult for some telescopes to observe it, as they could only get snippets of time (about an hour or less) each night to catch it before it set with the Sun. As a result, a coordinated combination of telescopes worldwide and in space was needed to observe the event in a series of short segments as we raced the sunset around the world as the Earth turned."

Professor Peter Veitch, University of Adelaide’s Head of Physics and Node-Leader of the ARC Centre of Excellence for Gravitational Wave Discovery

"Before this first-ever detection of a binary neutron-star merger, electromagnetic telescopes could see the gamma rays emitted by a merger but didn't know what caused it.

"When the LIGO-Virgo collaboration made the landmark detection of gravitational waves, we could identify the source of the gravitational waves but only knew approximately the location. Now we know both what happened and where it happened – multi-messenger gravitational astronomy has been born."

Associate Professor David Ottaway, chief investigator at the ARC Centre of Excellence for Gravitational Wave Discovery at The University of Adelaide

"We’ve now seen the first event using multi-messenger gravitational astronomy but with improved sensitivity we can observe many more of these cosmic events.

"With more observations, we will be able to build a clear picture of the evolution of our stars and galaxies and the birth and development of the universe. Here at the University of Adelaide we working with LIGO and OzGrav colleagues to improve the sensitivity of the current detectors and developing the technology for the next generation of detectors."

Dr Douglas Bock, director of CSIRO Astronomy and Space Science

"Here at CSIRO we are excited to be part of this discovery where we have turned some of the world’s best radio telescopes and joined them together with the gravity wave detectors and other telescopes around the world to try and understand the nature of gravity waves coming from across the Universe.

"The Australia Telescope Compact Array, operated by CSIRO, just had its 25th birthday but we are keeping it up to date so that it is ready for these kinds of discoveries – we can turn it with just a few hours to the most exciting things happening in the Universe.

"We have a program where astronomers like Tara Murphy, at the University of Sydney, can come in with just a couple of hours’ notice and completely reschedule the telescope to follow up the latest exciting scientific discoveries while they are going on.

"The current program with the Australia Telescope Compact Array has been going now for 40 hours since the gravity waves were first discovered. It’s an ongoing program in collaboration with telescopes all around the world."

Associate Professor Tara Murphy, the University of Sydney and the Centre of Excellence for All-Sky Astrophysics (CAASTRO)

"[After seeing the report from LIGO] We immediately rang our team in Australia and told them to get onto the CSIRO telescope as soon as possible, then started planning our observations. We were lucky in a sense in that it was perfect timing, but you have to be at the top of your game to play in this space. It is intense, time-critical science."

Professor Tamara Davis, the ARC Centre of Excellence for All-Sky Astrophysics (CAASTRO) and The University of Queensland

"This is a landmark discovery for astrophysics. It uncovers a whole new way of measuring the universe. Even just this one event where we see the explosion that accompanied these gravitational waves, already confirms many predictions — such as how the heavy elements were created, what happens when neutron stars collide, and how fast is the universe expanding."

WATCH MORE: Science & Health News


Comments

Be the first to comment on this story!

Trending Stories Right Now