It appears that the Trump administration has an opportunity to undo the reopening of diplomatic relations with Cuba — just like it wanted to do. Following unexplained “covert sonic device” attacks on envoys from both the US and Canada that were stationed in Havana, the US State Department is pulling more than half of its staff out of Cuba, and warning travellers of potential danger.
According to The Washington Post, officials are now acknowledging at least 21 Americans stationed at the Cuban embassy have suffered symptoms that include “hearing loss, dizziness, tinnitus, balance problems, visual difficulties, headaches, fatigue, cognitive issues and sleeping difficulties”. (Buzzfeed News puts the number at 25.) The Canadian government has previously confirmed that 10 of its diplomats suffered similar health problems. But the range of symptoms and the fact that the victims have reported different experiences while in Cuba has made it difficult to pin down exactly what is causing harm to these government workers. The decision on Friday to bring staff home is fuelled in part by the Cuban government’s inability to explain what is happening and offer assurances that it won’t happen again.
Friday’s developments added two new factors to this diplomatic crisis: The US is now explicitly calling the episodes “attacks”, and it’s warning travellers that they could also be at risk. The Washington Post reports:
Senior State Department officials said embassy employees had been “targeted” for “specific attacks” that are ongoing, a significant change from previous characterizations of what happened as simply “incidents.”
Some of the diplomats were injured in a hotel in the Cuban capital near the embassy. The officials said they know of no other guests or employees of the hotel who were affected, but concern others might be hurt led them to issue a warning advising against travel to Cuba.
“It appears U.S. Embassy personnel are most at risk,” said one official, speaking anonymously under State Department ground rules for briefing reporters. “But I can’t rule out the American public travelling in Cuba might (also) be at risk.”
Only “emergency personnel” will remain at the embassy and there won’t be enough staff leftover to process any future visas.
Secretary of State Rex Tillerson appeared on Face the Nation on September 17 and indicated that closing the embassy, at least temporarily, was “under evaluation”. Earlier this week, Tillerson met with Cuban Foreign Minister Bruno Eduardo Rodriguez Parrilla to discuss the situation and reportedly came away without any feelings of reassurance. A Cuban readout of the meeting was obtained by CBS News:
“The Cuban government has never perpetrated nor will it ever perpetrate attacks of any kind against diplomats,” it read. “The Cuban government has never permitted nor will it ever permit the use of its territory by third parties for this purpose.”
The readout went on to say that Cuban authorities had so far found, “There is no evidence so far of the cause or the origin of the health disorders reported by the U.S. diplomats.”
Experts have been baffled by the reports of hearing damage that may have been caused by “an advanced sonic weapon that operated outside the range of audible sound”, as the supposed “laser-like specificity” that would be necessary in such a case appears to be outside of the capabilities of known devices. Victims have reported hearing “loud ringing or a high-pitch chirping similar to crickets or cicadas” that was isolated in a tiny portion of a room, while others never noticed anything unusual before their symptoms began. On top of that, officials told the Associated Press that it seemed unlikely that all of the reported symptoms could be caused by the same thing. “The physics don’t add up,” one official who was not authorised to speak on the record said.
While it’s certainly embarrassing that the US State Department and intelligence community is saying that they don’t understand what’s happening, there will be many in the US government who are happy that this is happening. President Trump and Tillerson have both recently expressed their dissatisfaction with President Obama’s decision to renew relations with Cuba in 2014 after 54-year-long trade embargo.
Members of Congress who are against any relationship with Cuba, such as Marco Rubio, have seized this moment to demand a complete withdrawal over the last few weeks. On Friday, Rubio tweeted that the Cuban embassy in Washington DC should be closed as well. “So Castro regime allows attacks on Americans forcing us to drawdown to keep them safe but he gets to keep about same # of people here,” he asked.
If chaos is the motive of whomever’s responsible for the diplomatic attacks in Cuba, it seems safe to say that they’re winning.