Modest reductions in measles vaccination rates among US children are poised to produce an inordinate number of new cases of the disease, while increasing annual public health expenditures by at least $3 million, according to new research.
User computer models, researchers from the Stanford University School of Medicine and Baylor College of Medicine have shown that a five per cent reduction in measles vaccinations among children between the ages of two and 11 would triple the number of annual measles cases among this group. What’s more, the associated public health costs would run upwards of $US2.1 ($3) million, or $US20,000 ($25,276) per case of measles. These troubling findings were published earlier today in JAMA Pediatrics.
"We focused on measles as a case example of the effects of declining vaccine coverage because it is highly infectious," said Stanford's Nathan Lo, the study's lead author in a statement. "It's likely to be the first infectious disease causing outbreaks if vaccination declines."
No doubt. Several regions in the United States are currently flirting with the 90 to 95 per cent vaccine coverage threshold required to prevent measles outbreaks, a group-wide level of protection known as herd immunity. With routine childhood vaccination rates declining in some parts of the United States, there's an increased risk for isolated outbreaks, such as the one that struck an Amish community back in 2014. The new study predicts a sharp increase in measles within certain communities should vaccination rates decline much further.
"I think our study is a wake-up call for what we can expect in the coming months and years as vaccine coverage rates continue to decline in the 18 states that now allow non-medical or philosophical belief exemptions," said study co-author Peter Hotez.
Measles, which starts with fever, coughing, and sore throat, is a highly contagious virus that spreads through the air. Common complications include ear infections and diarrhoea, but around one in 20 children who contract the disease get pneumonia -- the most common cause of death from measles in young children, according to the US Centres for Disease Control. Vaccinations have been largely successful at suppressing measles in the US, but a few dozen to a few hundred cases occur each year, typically when unvaccinated citizens travel abroad and unknowingly bring the virus back with them.
Currently, all 50 US states require the measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccine and other vaccinations prior to enrolling a child in daycare of elementary school. Only three states allow parents to decline vaccinations for religious reasons, and as noted, 18 states have provisions for personal beliefs. Infants under the age of one cannot be vaccinated, making them particularly vulnerable to the disease.
For the study, Lo and his colleagues analysed MMR vaccination data provided by the CDC. They built a mathematical model to predict the effects of declining vaccination rates in children aged two to eleven. Around 10,000 scenarios were run through the model, all of them kickstarted by hypothetical travellers who returned to different locations in the country.
The researchers said their figures tended toward the conservative, and that their measles model didn't include other infectious diseases that are likely to arise with lower vaccination coverage (e.g. mumps, pertussis, etc.). Also, the researchers didn't account for the spread of the disease among other age groups. Finally, they used the lowest possible level of infectiousness that is reasonable for measles. Despite this conservative approach, the disease still predicted substantial medical and health related consequences of so-called "vaccine hesitation."
"Every year, an increasing number of states are debating non-medical exemptions, which are a critical driver of vaccination coverage," said Lo. "This study quantifies the consequences of a rise in measles cases and state dollars that will be spent if personal belief exemptions that can reduce vaccine coverage are in place."
Just keep immunizing your kids, folks. For them, and your community. [JAMA Pediatrics]