PG Logo
  • Business Insider
  • Kotaku
  • Lifehacker
  • Openair Cinemas
  • Pedestrian.TV
Logo The News Of Tomorrow, Today
Subscribe
  • Reviews
    • Camera
    • Car
    • Entertainment
    • Gadgets & Smart Home
    • Gaming
    • Laptop & Tablet
    • PC & Peripheral
    • Smartphone
    • Smartwatch and Fitness Tracker
    • View All Reviews
  • Smart Home & Gadgets
  • Mobile
  • Cars
  • Online
  • Science & Health
  • Cameras
  • Computing
  • Gaming
  • Entertainment
  • Reviews
    • Camera
    • Car
    • Entertainment
    • Gadgets & Smart Home
    • Gaming
    • Laptop & Tablet
    • PC & Peripheral
    • Smartphone
    • Smartwatch and Fitness Tracker
    • View All Reviews
  • Smart Home & Gadgets
  • Mobile
  • Cars
  • Online
  • Science & Health
  • Cameras
  • Computing
  • Gaming
  • Entertainment

Want Gizmodo's email newsletter?

Follow us, subscribe and get in touch

  • Contact Gizmodo Australia
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • RSS

Recent Posts

This New Google Chrome Feature Lets You Link To Highlighted Website Text
This New Google Chrome Feature Lets You Link To Highlighted Website...
The Internet Reacts To The Original Star Wars
Image: Supplied
The Internet Reacts To The Original Star Wars
Prince Philip’s Funeral Hearse Was A Modified Land Rover Defender
Prince Philip’s Funeral Hearse Was A Modified Land Rover Defender
Courteney Cox Will Face Suburban Terrors in Starz Horror Comedy Shining Vale
Courtney Cox and Greg Kinner in Shining Vale (Image: Starz)
Courteney Cox Will Face Suburban Terrors in Starz Horror Comedy Shining...
Crypto Market Plummets Following Week of Coinbase-fuelled Hype
Photo: Dan Kitwood, Getty Images
Crypto Market Plummets Following Week of Coinbase-fuelled Hype

Deals

The Best Camera Deals for Bodies, Lenses and Accessories Right Now
Image: iStock/EKKAPHAN CHIMPALEE

The Best Camera Deals for Bodies, Lenses and Accessories Right Now

Dodo’s NBN 50 Plan Is Now as Fast as Optus and Telstra
Image: Scrubs
Dodo’s NBN 50 Plan Is Now as Fast as Optus and...
Get 70% Off Sennheiser’s Momentum 2 Headphones Right Now
Image: sennheiser
Get 70% Off Sennheiser’s Momentum 2 Headphones Right Now
Tangerine Is Offering a $25 NBN 50 Plan Right Now
Image: Friends
Tangerine Is Offering a $25 NBN 50 Plan Right Now
You Can Finally Store Your PS5 Games on an External Drive, so Get a Portable SSD
Image: Sony Interactive Entertainment
You Can Finally Store Your PS5 Games on an External Drive,...

Sponsored Articles

Your Metadata: It’ll Cost About $400m, But Now It’s Political

Share
Campbell Simpson

Campbell Simpson

Published 6 years ago: February 18, 2015 at 2:00 pm -
Filed to:afp
asioclipsdata retentionfeaturegovernmentiinetmetadataoptustelstravodafone
Your Metadata: It’ll Cost About $400m, But Now It’s Political
To sign up for our daily newsletter covering the latest news, features and reviews, head HERE. For a running feed of all our stories, follow us on Twitter HERE. Or you can bookmark the Gizmodo Australia homepage to visit whenever you need a news fix.

Data retention legislation continues to percolate, although the government is trying to push it through parliament as soon as possible — and could potentially have a capturing and monitoring system in place before March. Despite both Liberal and Labor parties generally being in favour of it, there’s a bit of trouble brewing in our Orwellian paradise.

Smartphone image via Shutterstock

Prime Minister Tony Abbott has done the maths and says that the absolute maximum cost of a data retention program would top out at $400 million — that’s 1 per cent of the value of Australia’s $40 billion telecommunications industry. Given that second-largest telco Optus pegs the cost at $200m, that Abbott quote seems sketchy.

The cost of not ramming through the legislation, though, would be incalculably higher according to Abbott — due to an “explosion in unsolved crime” from law enforcement agencies not having access to the crucial metadata apparently invaluable in identifying, tracking down and prosecuting criminals who use the Australian internet and telecommunications networks to communicate and conduct their illegal activities. Abbott says the retention of metadata would go a long way in the fight against terrorists, pedophiles and corporate fraudsters.

Here’s the problem — this rhetoric doesn’t really sound like something that you could quantify — you can’t put a number on crimes that you don’t know about. Moreover, Abbott’s comment ignores the fact that Australian law enforcement agencies like the AFP and ASIO already successfully catch and prosecute individuals without the expanded, on-demand access to metadata that they have requested. Existing legislation allows agencies to access currently-retained metadata, as long as warrant conditions were met.

Last Week In Your Metadata: Government Wants It, Telcos Don’t Mind

Shadow communications minister Jason Clare talked to Sky News to offer a carefully dissenting opinion:

Clare, who is a member of the parliamentary Joint Standing Committee on Intelligence and Security, said that while metadata is “very important” for the day-to-day operations of Australia’s law enforcement — using the example of police checking the phone and internet records of a person being killed, despite no witnesses at the scene of the crime, to establish any persons of interest.

Despite that value, Clare echoed Labor Party leader and Leader of the Opposition Bill Shorten in saying that the strict definition of what consitutes metadata should be encapsulated in legislation and laid out clearly rather than being left up to agency self-regulation. /”All the telcos” are already in favour of strict definition, as are industry groups.

Similarly, the Labor Party wants the clear costs of data retention to be made public. The issue is largely a bipartisan one but Shorten has recently said that the government’s politicisation of the matter threatens the party’s unqualified support, and Clare told Sky News “this is too important for politics”. The lack of provisions to protect the work and confidential sources of journalists is also a sticking point.

About the Author

Campbell Simpson

Campbell Simpson

  • Posts
  • Email

Share this Story
Get our Newsletter Subscribe
There are no more articles to be viewed

© 2007 - 2021 Pedestrian Group

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Haven't registered? Sign up here
Lost your password? Click here to reset

Back to Login? Click here

Email newsletters will contain a brief summary of our top stories, plus details of competitions and reader events.

Back to Login? Click here

Subscribe to our newsletter!

Now you can get the top stories from Gizmodo delivered to your inbox. Enter your email below.

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.