PG Logo
  • Business Insider
  • Kotaku
  • Lifehacker
  • Openair Cinemas
  • Pedestrian.TV
Logo The News Of Tomorrow, Today
Subscribe
  • Reviews
    • Camera
    • Car
    • Entertainment
    • Gadgets & Smart Home
    • Gaming
    • Laptop & Tablet
    • PC & Peripheral
    • Smartphone
    • Smartwatch and Fitness Tracker
    • View All Reviews
  • Smart Home & Gadgets
  • Mobile
  • Cars
  • Online
  • Science & Health
  • Cameras
  • Computing
  • Gaming
  • Entertainment
  • Reviews
    • Camera
    • Car
    • Entertainment
    • Gadgets & Smart Home
    • Gaming
    • Laptop & Tablet
    • PC & Peripheral
    • Smartphone
    • Smartwatch and Fitness Tracker
    • View All Reviews
  • Smart Home & Gadgets
  • Mobile
  • Cars
  • Online
  • Science & Health
  • Cameras
  • Computing
  • Gaming
  • Entertainment

Want Gizmodo's email newsletter?

Follow us, subscribe and get in touch

  • Contact Gizmodo Australia
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • RSS

Recent Posts

Google TV Brings Kids Profiles to an Already Fantastic Streaming Device
Google TV Brings Kids Profiles to an Already Fantastic Streaming Device
Scientists Warn Diphtheria Is on the Rise, Could Become Major Global Threat Again
Scientists Warn Diphtheria Is on the Rise, Could Become Major Global...
Star Trek: Picard’s Showrunner Just Dropped a Distressing Amount of Information on Romulan Romance
Star Trek: Picard’s Showrunner Just Dropped a Distressing Amount of Information...
Mars Rover Landing Site Named After Sci-Fi Legend Octavia Butler
Mars Rover Landing Site Named After Sci-Fi Legend Octavia Butler
WandaVision Had 2 Very Different TV Show Homages Planned
WandaVision Had 2 Very Different TV Show Homages Planned

Deals

Keep an Eye on the Road With This Voice Activated Dash Cam

Keep an Eye on the Road With This Voice Activated Dash Cam

You Can Score Free Galaxy Buds Pro With Any of Telstra’s S21 Plans
You Can Score Free Galaxy Buds Pro With Any of Telstra’s...
You Can Score Up to $160 off Samsung Galaxy Products Today
You Can Score Up to $160 off Samsung Galaxy Products Today
You Can Score Up to 60% Off Garmin Watches Today
You Can Score Up to 60% Off Garmin Watches Today
You Can Grab This Budget Lenovo Smart Tablet and Dock Bundle for $230
You Can Grab This Budget Lenovo Smart Tablet and Dock Bundle...

Sponsored Articles

George Brandis: We Won’t Use Metadata To Catch Pirates, Honest

Share

Luke Hopewell

Published 6 years ago: November 4, 2014 at 11:30 am -
Filed to:feature
george brandismetadatapiracy
George Brandis: We Won’t Use Metadata To Catch Pirates, Honest
To sign up for our daily newsletter covering the latest news, features and reviews, head HERE. For a running feed of all our stories, follow us on Twitter HERE. Or you can bookmark the Gizmodo Australia homepage to visit whenever you need a news fix.


The Government is on a massive sales drive this month, trying to convince the Australian people that a mandatory metadata retention scheme is a good idea, despite the fact that the country’s most senior federal policeman said his agency would use it to chase pirates. Attorney General George Brandis went on national television last night to try and correct the record.

When the metadata scheme was unveiled at a press conference held by Communications Minister, Malcolm Turnbull, Attorney General, George Brandis and Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police, Andrew Colvin, one fairly regrettable thing was said by the Commissioner: once we have this data, we can use it to prosecute pirates.

Ever since then, Turnbull and Brandis have been backpedalling as quickly as possible.

On the ABC’s Q&A last night, Brandis kicked the backpedalling into high gear. The short version? If you’re a pirate, don’t panic about data retention.

Brandis said that the metadata retention scheme will only be used to target criminals, not civil infringers of copyright. The AG added that Commissioner Colvin misspoke at the initial press conference.

[Metadata laws] can’t be and they won’t be [used to catch pirates]. Commissioner [Andrew] Colvin has corrected his remarks…he’s indicated that that’s not what he meant.

The mandatory metadata retention regime applies only to the most serious crime. To terrorism, to international and transnational crime, to paedophelia where it has been particularly useful as an investigative tool. Only to crime and only to the highest levels of crime.

Breaches of copyright is a civil wrong. Civil wrongs have got nothing to do with this scheme.

This isn’t to say that Brandis isn’t interested in catching pirates. That’s not the case at all.

AG Brandis is not only the architect of new laws to retain metadata, he’s also working on the largest anti-piracy scheme in Australia’s history.

What’s more likely is that the anti-piracy scheme will be used to catch pirates, as well as other industry-standard practices used overseas already.

Turnbull at the initial press conference attempted to water down the Commissioner’s statements, giving insights into how rights holders pursue pirates. At the time, this is how the Communications Minister described it:

A lot of internet piracy, downloading and sharing material is done by way of file-sharing, but the way that works is a torrent stream is created in which there are a whole number of computers with their own IPs that are sharing this pirated content. What the rights owners do is they use different programs to participate in the swarm and identify the IP addresses of the computers infringing copyright, and then they seek from the ISPs via subpoena the account details of the holder. They do this pretty much in real-time so the two year holding of data doesn’t make a big difference in terms of copyright infringement, they’re dealing with the here and now. The police commissioners interests tend to be much longer. It is relevant and it happens all the time.

Do you think metadata will still be used to prosecute pirates? Do you trust the government with your metadata? Tell us in the comments!

About the Author

Luke Hopewell

  • Posts
  • Email

Luke Hopewell | Gizmodo Editor






A self-professed gadget lover and nonsense talker geek, Luke Hopewell sits in the editor chair at Gizmodo Australia. He loves anything that switches on, does internet or goes fast. He picked up a Best New Aussie IT Journo Award in 2010 and if you stick around long enough, you’ll find Luke on your telly, too.

Share this Story
Get our Newsletter Subscribe
There are no more articles to be viewed

© 2007 - 2021 Pedestrian Group

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

Haven't registered? Sign up here
Lost your password? Click here to reset

Back to Login? Click here

Email newsletters will contain a brief summary of our top stories, plus details of competitions and reader events.

Back to Login? Click here

Subscribe to our newsletter!

Now you can get the top stories from Gizmodo delivered to your inbox. Enter your email below.

By subscribing you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.