If you were hanging around the internet yesterday afternoon, you probably noticed some hubbub around Google’s new, unified Terms of Service Agreement. Let’s step back from the emotion (and one writer’s opinion), and take a cool-headed, analytical look at what the new policies might actually mean for you:
Is This Worth Abandoning Google Over?
We have given you a guide of alternatives to Google services should you want to abandon ship entirely. There are certainly reasons to be concerned about keeping all of your eggs in one basket. It means there’s a single point of failure, which makes me nervous. Thet fact that you can’t opt-out, and that Google will know more about you than your wife? That’s a little creepy.
At the same time, it’s extremely convenient to have all of your eggs in one basket — you always know exactly where they are. Plus Google’s services play nicely together in a number of time-saving ways. Weighing convenience against security risks is your decision to make. I personally don’t see the new Terms of Service have having added any additional risk to the equation. Your YouTube and Gmail accounts had the same password before, and they still will. Personally, I was willing to risk it before, and I’ll continue to do so.
But make up your own mind. Read the new Terms of Service yourself. Compare it with the old Terms of Service. Compare it with the Terms of Service of other companies offering similar products. It’s up to you to make an informed decision. Time to use the old think-bucket.
How Will Sharing My Data Google-Wide Affect Me?
One of the chief gripes about the change is that Google will “track” you through across all of its services. Just to clarify: Google has always stored user data. Have you noticed how in Google Maps sometimes an address you searched for a year ago will auto-fill in? Well, now one Google application can see what you searched for in another, so if you searched for “Furbies” on Google’s homepage (for some freaky reason) and then later went to YouTube, you might see Furbies videos pop up. That’s new. Previously data was compartmentalized between applications.
That could be a bad thing if Google was changing its policies on the data it shares with third parties, after all Google+ knows your real name, right?. Fortunately, that isn’t the case (more on that in a sec). You know how your contacts are currently shared across Gmail, Calendar, and Docs? It’s going to be like that, except with everything, everywhere. If you already trust Google with your data, this isn’t that different. At the end of the day, the only change you might notice are some search improvements. Google’s example:
We can provide reminders that you’re going to be late for a meeting based on your location, your calendar and an understanding of what the traffic is like that day.
That actually sounds kind of awesome and not at all unlike what Apple’s Siri can do, except across a broader range of services. And you can’t turn it off.
Will This Make Targeted Ads Too Targeted?
There is a lot of talk of how now ads will be super targeted to you. For a long time Google’s ads have been “personalized” to you by pulling data out of your searches. The concern is that now it will be pulling from this larger, more unified, more personal shared data pool. But there is one very important thing to note: you can turn it off!
Ads Preferences Manager
The other very important thing to note is that Google has not changed its policies on sharing data with third parties. From Google’s blog post:
We don’t sell your personal information, nor do we share it externally without your permission except in very limited circumstances like a valid court order.
If you want more specifics, read up on it here.
Is Google Search Way Too Personal Now?
Our Mat Honan didn’t like Google’s new “Search Plus Your World” feature, which places Google+ search results (when there are some) above regular search results. After using it for a while I found it to be more annoying than useful, and it degrades the quality of your search results. You may feel differently. Either way, under Google’s new Terms of Service, you can still turn it off.
What’s the Impact on Android?
As of now, it doesn’t appear that your user experience on Android will change in any significant way. If you did want to minimise your Google footprint on an Android phone, you could:
You could also into Settings>Location services and uncheck Google’s location service and Location & Google Search. You can even set the browser’s default search engine to something other than Google if you want. Google Wallet will remain under a separate Terms of Service and will not be affected by any of this. So it’s cool, the fake money in your fake wallet is safe.
Important: Apps are harder, because we don’t have the Amazon App Store as an Android Market alternative like the US does.