This past weekend, a NASA-sanctioned 400-mile (643km) “personal air vehicle” race was held in Santa Rosa, CA, to see who had created the quietest, most fuel-efficient plane that’s still reasonably fast. Those involved hope pushing these ideas forward will make personal airplanes cost effective someday. These PAVs run as quiet as a pickup truck while averaging a fuel efficiency of 25 to 30 miles per gallon (10-13 km per litre). Four planes showed up for the challenge and US$100,000 in prize money was awarded, though the most intriguing craft of them all, a modded DA-20 that runs partially on biodiesel, was unable to compete because of a faulty sensor. In the end, the big winner was the Pipistrel Virus, a two-seater with tech-happy features such as three GPS modules, terrain visualization screen and a rocket-propelled parachute that deploys in the event of a mid-air collision. Here’s a look at all four contenders:
GSE Katana DA-20 Plane With Omnivore Biodiesel Engine
Awards Won: None
This modded Diamond Katana DA-20 plane was probably the most innovative and exciting plane in the challenge with its biodiesel capability, but due to a faulty inlet sensor, it was unable to compete. Designed by Greg and Geoff Stevenson and their aircraft engine company, GSE, the Omnivore only relies on biodiesel for auxiliary power during takeoff and landing. But the plan is to get it FAA certified step-by-step so that it relies more on the eco-friendly fuel. The engine also has an electric motor and fuel injection to help make the craft quieter and more fuel efficient. It was expected to win the Green Prize handily, which would have been awarded to any plane averaging over 30 mpg for the race, but none of the others could meet that requirement.
Awards Won: Safety Prize, Shortest Takeoff Distance, Quietest Cabin Noise, 400 Mile Race Winner, Best Angle of Climb
The Pipistrel Virus took home more awards than any other craft, but the team was still disappointed with their results, as it had performed better in some categories last year. The US$100k craft has a constant propeller speed switch that helps with fuel efficiency (28.8 MPG for the competition), as well as heavy sound dampening where it tied the Lambada motoglider for lowest cabin noise at 91.5 db. The plane flew 233 km per hour, and only required 280 metres for takeoff.
Pipistrel even flew out a team of engineers from Slovenia to install a new engine that was supposed to improve power and mileage, but it didn’t quite work out. What did work out was the super high-tech dashboard, normally found in much more expensive planes, with the aforementioned three GPS modules and a panel that can take map data and can digitally recreate the surrounding geography when visibility is poor.
Awards Won: Lowest Community Noise, Quietest LSA, Lowest Cabin Noise
Running as quietly as a pickup truck, the sexily named UFM-13 Lambada motoglider took home prizes for having the lowest community noise, at 62dB. According to team leader John Dunham, the plane would have also won the Best Glide Ratio award—this measures the amount a plane can move forward once it cuts power and eases back towards the ground, and the UFM-13 is apparently able to glide at a similar rate as a feather—but miscalculations due to human error prevented that from happening. Few mods were made to the plane itself, other than noise dampening measures. For the challenge, it managed to fly 210 kph, averaged 26.5 mpg and required 308 metres for takeoff.
Flight Design CT
Awards Won: Best Glide Ratio
Spearheaded by freelance aircraft mechanic Bob Bashim, this Flight Design CT didn’t have the resources of some of the other teams, but managed to snag the Best Glide Ratio prize. Bashim had some neat ideas to reduce noise and fuel consumption, including the use of a motorcycle muffler on his plane. Other measures taken for the challenge include adding noise dampening panels around the engine, and removing all unnecessary weight around the plane.
— — —
Though most of the participants started working on this only 6 weeks ago, they are already looking forward to next year, with more time to work on their planes. Pipistrel’s team in particular is interested in the idea of shorter takeoff lengths, where people could have their own runways, and wouldn’t have to use a regional airport to hit the skies. For more information on the challenge, check out the homepage of the [CAFE Foundation] .