Ethics aside, espionage is an indispensable part of statecraft. The Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance (ISR) information gathered helps steer national policy decisions for everything from mundane trade negotiations to the blackest of ops.
And nowhere is this more evident than in the development of the US spy satellite fleet during the Cold War. These orbital telescopes granted an unprecedented peek over the Iron Curtain — revealing Soviet military capabilities, supply reserves, industrial sites and more — that no ground-based spook could hope to provide.
During the Cold War, accurately ascertaining the USSR’s military capabilities was a top US priority — as well it should have been given that we had as many as 21,000 nuclear warheads pointed at each other during that time. And while we had plenty of spies operating in Moscow, the view from overhead provided the President and his cabinet key insights into the extent of Soviet strategic capabilities which influenced defence planning and arms control negotiations. As such, the US invested vast sums of money into high-altitude research — from early “weather balloons” to the SR-71 Blackbird and U2 Dragon Lady to orbital telescopes — and established not one but three Federal agencies — the National Reconnaissance Office (NRO), the National Security Agency (NSA), and the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) — all in an effort to glean any speck of information that could give us an advantage.
Satellite technology is, by far, the most expensive ISR method at the US’s disposal but also the most effective, its results well worth the billions of dollars spent. As President Lyndon B. Johnson famously quipped in 1967 after a Soviet hoax led to worries of a bomber gap:
I wouldn’t want to be quoted on this … We’ve spent $US35 or $US40 billion on the space program. And if nothing else had come out of it except the knowledge that we gained from space photography, it would be worth 10 times what the whole program has cost. Because tonight we know how many missiles the enemy has and, it turned out, our guesses were way off. We were doing things we didn’t need to do. We were building things we didn’t need to build. We were harboring fears we didn’t need to harbor.
Of course, much of the development of our national reconnaissance capabilities is still shrouded in veils of classification. Heck, the NRO was established in 1961 and operated for three decades before the government even ever acknowledged its existence. Press reports made limited references to the agency as far back as 1971, but it wasn’t until the Deputy Secretary of defence revealed the NRO in 1992, was it ever formally discussed by the DoD. Oversight from the DoD and Congress was virtually non-existent save for the “open-checkbook” policy of the times. As long as the intelligence justified the price tag, any cost was acceptable. It wasn’t until the early 1990’s that any information on these devices was declassified, after the fall of the Soviet Union brought an end to the Cold War. Even now, information on the early satellites is sparse and anything after 1972 is non-existent save for a few photos taken by the KH-11 satellite which were leaked to Jane’s Defence Weekly in 1985.
What we do know is that the US has been researching high-altitude reconnaissance technology since about 1946 when the RAND project, precursor to Rand Corp., began campaigning for its development. When the Army and Navy couldn’t agree on who would have control over the orbital technology, it was assigned to the newly-formed USAF in 1947. It took a few years for RAND researchers working on “Project Feedback” to figure out how a satellite would even function — this was a brand new technological concept, mind you — but by 1953 they had not only devised the general characteristics and capabilities of a reconnaissance satellite but had begun to develop many of the components as well, like the television system and altimeter. The Atomic Energy Commission also began work on miniaturized nuclear power sources for the vehicles at that time. By 1954, the USAF accepted RAND’s assertion that the technology was of “vital strategic interest to the United States” and officially established the US satellite program.
The Corona Program
The first such program was the Corona project, a codeword itself code named “Discoverer” for the public explanation of why the government was firing a rocket into space (a rare event in the late 1950s that would have attracted a curious public and international scrutiny). The program began in 1959 at the Onizuka Air Force Station, ran until 1972, and was declassified in 1995 by President Clinton. Its initial budget was a modest $US108.2 million ($860 million adjusted to 2013), though that quickly increased following the 1960 incident in which Gary Powers’ U2 was shot down over Soviet airspace. The 144-member family of Corona satellites — each designated Keyhole-#, or KH-#, depending on the spacecraft iteration — were produced and operated by the CIA in conjunction with the USAF and provided invaluable photographic surveillance of the Soviet Union as well as the People’s Republic of China, and other Communist countries.
Launched aboard a Thor booster rocket and Agena spacecraft, these satellites relied on a pair of 1.5m long stereoscopic Itek cameras using 12-inch, f/5 triplet lenses and a 24-inch focal length (later models also incorporated a third “index” camera for reference). The early cameras could achieve a 12m resolution. By KH-3, optical improvements decreased that figure to 6m. Later missions continued to halve the resolution until researchers were able to resolve one-foot wide objects, realised that that was way too close to be of any strategic use and backed off to a more manageable 1m resolution.
They were fed a special Eastman Kodak 70mm film that produced 170 lines per mm — more than three times the 50 lines/mm resolution earlier WWII aerial photography could compose. The first Coronas carried a paltry 8000 feet of film — per camera — though through improvements in the film chemistry and design reduced the material thickness, researchers were eventually able to double that amount. The cameras themselves underwent numerous upgrades as well, elongating to nine feet and incorporating panoramic Petzval f/3.5 lenses.
Once the camera had run through its full complement of film, it would eject the roll via a reentry capsule designed by General Electric. After the capsule discarded its heat shield at 60,000 feet, it deployed a parachute and could either be nabbed by a passing plane equipped with a claw hook (above) or land safely in the ocean where it would float for two days awaiting pickup. If the capsule wasn’t retrieved within 48 hours, a salt plug at the bottom of the canister would dissolve and sink it. If it was picked up in time, the film would be transported to Rochester, New York, for processing at Eastman Kodak’s Hawkeye facility.
The Argon Program
The KH-5 ARGON ran in conjunction with Corona from 1961 to 1964, though never with the same degree of success. These 1150 – 1500 kg satellites manufactured by Lockheed Martin and operated by the NR used a single 76mm focal length camera with a 140m resolution were operated primarily for map-making — they were the first to image Antarctica from space — and took less than a week to produce. Of the 12 flights attempted, however, only five successfully put the unit in orbit.
The Lanyard Program
The KH-6 Lanyard program was the NRO’s first attempt at high definition photography but lasted just six months and three launches in 1963, two of which failed to produce images. These 1500 kg Lockheed satellites were hastily constructed using the previously-cancelled Itek “E-5” camera in order to survey a rumoured anti-ballistic missile site near Tallinn, Estonia. The E-5 had a 168cm focal length and 1.8m resolution covering a 14km x 74km area. The only successful flight returned 910 photographic frames. However, the image quality was so poor that they were virtually useless.
The Gambit Program
Outside of the Corona program, America’s initial attempts at satellite photo-reconnaissance failed more often than not. The KH-7 and KH-8 series, codenamed Gambit, were a marked departure from that trend and the only other predominantly successful satellite ISR program in the 1960s. This 3000kg Low Altitude Surveillance Platform developed by Lockheed flew just 75 miles up (Coronas orbited at 160km) and operated for nearly two decades from 1964 to 1984. No fewer than 54 such satellites launched (these things only worked for three months, tops) from Vandenberg AFB aboard Titan III rockets during that time.
Eastman Kodak’s A&O Division in Rochester, New York, produced the Gambit’s primary strip camera system. With a focal length of 446cm, a 6.3km wide coverage area, and 1m resolution, the KH-8 was ideal for gathering high-resolution images of Soviet sites. Unlike conventional aperture cameras, the Gambit’s slit camera reflected light off of a 48-inch mirror, through a slit aperture, and on to a moving length of Eastman Kodak Type 3404 film. It would then either drop the roll as the Coronas did or automatically develop the photographs, scan them, and transmit the images back to Earth in as little as 20 minutes through the Film Read-Out GAMBIT (FROG) feature (though after $US2 billion dollars and nearly a decade of development the 1971 administration nix(on)ed it).
In addition to keeping tabs on Soviet air capabilities, Gambit was also designed to photograph the spacecraft around it. This ability came in handy in 1973. The brand new Skylab had just launched when its meteoroid shield broke loose and damaged the space station. As NASA scrambled to send up a manned repair mission, the NRO launched a new Gambit, which snapped this picture and helped NASA engineers plan accordingly.
The HEXAGON Program
The KH-9 HEXAGON was, by all accounts, an unmitigated success with 19 of its 20 launches reaching orbit between 1971 and 1986. This $US3.262 billion Lockheed-built NRO program is officially deemed a Broad Coverage Photo Reconnaissance satellite but is better known as “Big Bird.” And while its existence wasn’t revealed until 2011, the program dates back to the 1960s as a successor to the Corona program.
The first generation of HEXAGON employed a pair of f/3.0 folded Wright Camera cameras with a 60-inch focal length able to resolve objects down to 2 feet and carried four re-entry vehicles. The last three generations featured a pair of panoramic cameras as well as upgraded electronics, C&C systems and nitrogen-supplied re-entry canisters. They also a began surviving longer. Most spy satellites have very limited life spans — two to three months — and once they’re out of film they have no further purpose. But with ever increasing film payloads, the final iteration of the KH-9 lasted 275 days in space. Between 1973 and 1980, these satellites imaged every square foot of the Earth in 29,000 pictures, much of it better quality than LANDSAT, a rival satellite mapping program. Most of these images have been declassified since 2002, though sensitive areas such as government installations and most of Israel remain tightly guarded.
The KENNAN Program
The KH-11 KENNAN is the most advanced recon satellite to be unclassified. First launched in 1976 by the NRO, it’s the first US satellite to employ an EO digital sensor and charge-coupled device (CCD), which reportedly provides an Enemy of the State-style real-time observation capability. Very little is known about the satellite’s hardware though many have speculated that its roughly the same size as the Hubble Space Telescope with a similar 2.4-meter mirror producing a six inch resolution. There’s also wide speculation that the KH-11 is the source of images declassified in the wake of the 1998 embassy bombings, as well as others of China and Russia declassified the year prior. The images the CIA used to find Osama bin Laden’s hideout were reportedly supplied by the KENNAN. Fifteen KH-11’s have been launched in total — nine between 1976 and 1990 aboard Titan-3D rockets, five between 1992 and 2005 aboard Titan IVs, and the final one in 2011 aboard a Delta IV — at an estimated cost of $US2.2 to 3 billion.
The end of the Cold War certainly put a damper on reconnaissance satellite funding, as did the rise of commercial satellite technology, but it remains a staple of our intelligence gathering resources. The technology has also found new use in providing tactical information to ground troops (not having to catch film canisters with sky hooks helps). Satellite imagery was first used in 1991 during Desert Shield and again in Iraq, Bosnia, Kosovo, and Afghanistan (above).
Pictures: NRO, CIA, NASA