What Would Happen If You Flew A Normal Plane Above Other Planets?

We're lucky enough to live on a planet where it's comparatively easy to design and build aeroplanes that work: our atmosphere and the Earth's gravitational pull are kind in that respect. But what would happen if you tried to fly a regular plane around another planet or moon?

As Randall Munroe points out in a new What If? post, in most cases, not a lot: there's no atmosphere on plenty of those celestial bodies, so a plane would fall straight out of the sky. On the few that do have an atmosphere — including Mars, Venus, the four gas giants, Saturn's moon Titan, and the sun — it's more difficult to say.

So Munroe took to X-Plane, a highly tweakable flight simulator which accurately models flight physics in-game. It's so tweakable, that it can simulate flight on other planets. So... that's what Munroe did. His results, which you can read over on What If?, are entertaining:

Our Cessna can't fly on Jupiter; the gravity is just too strong. The power needed to maintain level flight is three times greater than that on Earth. Starting from a friendly sea-level pressure, we'd accelerate through the tumbling winds into a 275 m/s (600 mph) downward glide deeper and deeper through the layers of ammonia ice and water ice until we and the aircraft were crushed. There's no surface to hit; Jupiter transitions smoothly from gas to solid as you sink deeper and deeper.

But there is one piece of good news. On Saturn's moon, Titan, a relatively low surface pressure and insanely low gravitational pull (weaker than our moon's), means even a pedal-powered plane could take off. You can — and should — read the whole post over on What If? ... and then maybe take a flight to Titan. [What If?]


Comments

    I'm pretty sure you could design a more efficient system for the moon assuming a colony was already there.

    Last edited 30/01/13 12:07 pm

      It's not so much about efficiency, but the simple fact that planes are designed with an atmosphere in mind - wings, propellors, etc. We'd basically need to design an entire new class of vehicles for flying on the moon. I think most likely, we'd simply remain on the ground using buggies.

        Agreed, given the lack of atmosphere and lower gravity ground travel can be much faster given the reduced friction, super high speed rail travel using magnets is more likely.

    To Ganymede and Titan, yessir I've been around...

      nice blade runner reference there...i applaud you good sir

        I was channelling Red Dwarf, but I'll take it anyway. Thanks :)

    All this supposes the motor will work without oxygen.

      If you actually bothered to read the whole article, you'd have noticed that it is specifically referring to using an electric powered motor, which to my (albeit limited) physics knowledge, does not require oxygen to produce power.

    I really like that picture, they should make a poster of it

    It does get quite windy around Uranus.

      Not to mention the Klingon threat!

    Your plane would fly pretty well, except it would be on fire the whole time, and then it would stop flying, and then stop being a plane.

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now