
Hard drives are terribly dull things — until you have to replace them, as our own Elly found out recently. Thankfully, even on heavily sealed systems, hard drive replacement is one of those jobs, like interior painting, that you should always do yourself.
There are countless terabytes of data stored on hard drives all over the world… just waiting to die. Over last week Gizmodo Australia’s own Elly Hart got a short sharp lesson in hard drive replacement and backup strategy, thanks to the hard drive on her iMac failing.
It’s always possible to pay somebody to replace just about any part of your PC you’d care to name, but the costs can be high, and sometimes stupidly so. Elly booked her iMac in with Apple to ascertain the problem — and the genius in charge was nice enough to do so on an out of warranty machine for free – but she wasn’t happy with the price that Apple wanted to charge.

Apple wanted $285 for the drive alone and $40 for the labour. The labour cost’s quite reasonable, but $285 for a 500GB internal drive? Madness. Elly quickly sourced a compatible 500GB drive for a much more reasonable $79, but this left her with the problem of actually fitting it into her iMac.
There’s a side lesson here: Back up your data. Sure, it’s boring to be lectured to, but it counts. If your computer flat out died when you finished reading this sentence, what would you do?

Elly’s problem was exacerbated by the fact that her computer of choice was an iMac. Pretty looking machines, iMacs, but a right pain to change anything but the memory on, as everything is built behind the screen, and as many online guides will tell you, you need suction cups to remove the screen.
Actually the guides are only half-right here; you do need suction cups to remove the primary LCD screen protector, which is magnetically held in place, but you’re not limited to buying expensive tools to achieve this purpose. Elly’s hard drive seller was nice enough to throw some suction cups in; I’ve had similar success with the suction cups on GPS screen mounts.
I’ve done the same hard drive swapping trick on an iMac myself a while back, and while it’s not the hardest job you’ll ever do — frankly, a lot of it is rather lego-esque in its simplicity — it’s handy to have an extra person on hand to help with all the bits and fiddly lifting and shifting; iMacs are fairly solidly constructed critters. The one thing I’d say here is that it’s well worth doing lots of reading and watching online; there are many, many guides but unless they relate to your specific model they’re not much cop at all.
Elly reckons it took her about 90 minutes to complete the swap of dead and living drives; that’s the one area where Apple’s quote was reasonable if not great for semi-specialised help. The actual drive swap’s stupidly easy — once you get over the dual issues of cracking the case and building up the nerve to do it.
Images: Elly Hart, mrbill, Collin Allen

















Ozoneocean
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 4:47 PMI absolutely hate replacing drives… I’ve swapped and replaced so many in different comps over the years. :(
I would hate it even more if I had to deal with suction cups. Jebus. Give me a big fridge of a tower any day.
-no fiddly laptop bits either. Ewww!
Mike
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 4:49 PM$79 for a 500Gb drive? Ouch! Silly hdd crisis…
Best guides for replacing anything in Macs I’ve found are here
http://www.ifixit.com/Browse/Mac. Great pics, great teardowns for many different models, all free to access! Ftw!
Main thing you want to be careful of when replacing anything in your iMac is keeping the LCD and front glass plate clean! Getting dust/marks/etc on there is a pain to get completely cleanly off :S
BenDTU
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 5:08 PMHoly crap – the 2TB WD Green drive I bought earlier in the year has DOUBLED in price since I got it.
SSDs seem unchanged though, which is interesting…
Todd
Wednesday, November 2, 2011 at 9:35 AMComponents for SSD’s arent made in Thailand, so it makes sense that SSD prices are normal. It’s not only Western Digital’s main manufacturing plants that are affected, but also the companies that supply other parts, such as the motors to spin the platters etc.
Rad
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 4:52 PMI don’t understand why everyone is so adamant on the idea of using suction cups to remove the glass. All you need is a large piece or two of gaffa tape on one of the corners.
Mike
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 5:03 PMPulling on one corner will likely end with you breaking the magnets that attach the glass to the frame. They’re little rods, and have to be pulled straight back. If you don’t, you’ll just snap ‘em off.
Rad
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 5:13 PMI’ve used this method before several times without any components ending up damaged. I’ll elaborate..
I use a piece of gaffa tape on the right hand corner angled at 45 degrees, firmly press down on it and then slowly pull on it until the glass breaks free of the magnet.
Once it breaks free, I put my right hand fingers in between the glass and bezel to keep it separated. At the same time, I put my left index finger in between the glass and bezel, then guide it along to the left hand corner until the glass is completely separated.
Obviously this isn’t a procedure you take recklessly.
Mike
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 5:18 PMYeah if you do it that gently I imagine it’s fine lol, just wanted to clear things up a leetle, i.e it’s not ok to just pull from one side to get it off. Seen many a missing magnet from people who’ve done that lol
smith
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 4:55 PMSwapped out my 2009 Macbook Pro’s HD last week. Now have a 500GB in two partitions. Would have loved an SSD, but I’ll let that wait for a complete new machine.
Rad
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 5:03 PMUnfortunate, an SSD would make it feel like a completely new machine!
Hah
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 5:08 PMYet another reason to steer clear of Macs, suction cups indeed!
Owen
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 5:54 PMThe newer iMacs use a 7-pin connector instead of a 4-pin, as OWC found out, making it impossible for anyone at home to swap HDDs in:
http://blog.macsales.com/10206-further-explained-apples-imac-2011-model-hard-drive-restrictions
Mike
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 6:11 PMYou can use the hdds, it just won’t pass the Apple Hardware Test (which is POS anyway heh)
step
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 9:12 PMI believe it will also mean the fans run flat out, since it uses the hard drives temperature sensor (possibly in conjuntion with others) to select the fan speed.
From the linked article:
“After startup, the HDD fan would start to ramp up from the 1100RPM base and into the 5600RPM range as reported by SMCFanControl.”
I wouldn’t recommend replacing a 2011 hard drive yourself (and Gizmodo probably should mention that the older model referenced is different to the current one).
nebarik
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 7:23 PM90 minutes, really? more of a 15 minute job if you know what your doing. and have the correct tools
the problem with doing the modern imacs at home is no one will have the proper cleaning gear for the inside of the glass. so you’ll end up with all this dust inside .
not to mention how many people break in the inside of imacs because they forget about the LVDS cable as they pull the LCD off, then your in trouble.
dave
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 8:52 PMfirst tips to upgrading HDD in an iMac
go get yourself a PC and it will only be a 5-10 mins job and you won’t be ripped off left right and centre by APPLE…..
markd
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 9:20 PMand swap your Audi for a Commodore while you’re at it, right?
WhiteDaemon666
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 9:36 PMDon’t you mean Falcon for a Commodore?
Fluffy
Tuesday, November 1, 2011 at 9:48 PMYou’ve never really researched the similarity of the parts in your Mac to a PC’s have you?
Michael
Wednesday, November 2, 2011 at 1:23 AMSo this is the reason why I have a Windows PC. Less crap to do when shit goes wrong. None of this crap taking it to Apple to get fixed or dealing with shoddy suppliers. Just walk into any computer store, grab the part and stick it in. Done!
Lillee
Wednesday, November 2, 2011 at 9:40 AMThis is one reason to stay sway from Macs… on any other laptop, there’s a simple eject hdd function or at least one screw cover removal to get at it.
Deev
Wednesday, November 2, 2011 at 10:07 AMHD’s in current Mac laptops are VERY easy to get to. Even installing a chassis in the optical slot for a 2nd HD is a quick job…
Mike
Wednesday, November 2, 2011 at 11:14 AMNot the latest models, no. Older MBPs and MBs had an easily removable cover, latest models you have to unscrew the entire bottom.
smith
Wednesday, November 2, 2011 at 5:11 PMMate, I replaced mine as I said above. Took about 10-15 mins. Just need the right screwdrivers and a magnetic tray to hold the tiny 3mm screws.
Kroo
Wednesday, November 2, 2011 at 8:24 PMI’ve had 4 Macs in 10 years and only one HD failure, and that took me 15 minutes on a MacBook Pro. All my PC friends go through drives like popcorn. Must be all that defraging they have to do (and the throwing of objects at the blue screen of death). It’s not rocket science.