Google Needs To Standardise The MicroUSB Positioning On Android Phones

Gizmodo AU

Apple and Google are currently battling a war over your pocket. And while each smartphone OS has its strengths and weaknesses, there is one weapon that Apple has with the power to decimate its Google enemies – the accessory market. It’s time for Google to fight back.

No matter what type of iPhone you have, you can rest assured that vast majority of the iAccessories you decide to buy – whether it be a speaker dock, an alarm clock, a portable charger, an IR transmitter or even just a simple charging cradle – will work with your iPhone (or iPod, for that matter). Those that don’t work are probably limited by Apple constantly changing the standard rather than there being an issue with the iDevice fitting the iAccessory.

Now compare that to the Android platform. Google’s openness when it comes to Android may allow manufacturers to create a wonderful variety of differently designed hardware, but that same openness means that there cannot be a universal accessory market for the platform.

The thing is, it probably wouldn’t be too hard for Google to make this change. All Android phones coming out now have a MicroUSB port for charging and connecting to a PC via USB. But the location of the port is far from universal – while some phones like the Nexus S have it dead centre on the bottom, others are slightly off centre while others have the port on the side of the phone.

Google needs to take control of the MicroUSB port’s positioning. By making it mandatory for all Android handset makers to place the port in the same place on the phone and dictating a maximum dimension for phones (width and depth, in particular), it could open the door for accessory manufacturers to begin creating custom designed peripherals for all Android devices, instead of just particular models.

Look at how iPhone speaker docks come today – each model has the basic 30-pin connector sticking up from the body of the speaker somewhere, but most come with a pack of custom plastic moulds that fit into the body to create a perfect fit for the iPod or iPhone you’re using.

The exact same approach could be used to accommodate the variety of shapes found in Android phones, so long as the important bit – the connection – was universally located in the same spot.

Not only is this a great move for consumers, allowing them to enjoy their Android devices in even more ways, it can also be a boon for Google and their partners. By creating a certification for Android accessories – think “Made for iPhone” with a little green man – they could both charge accessory makers for the certification as well as incentivising handset manufacturers to share in that revenue by becoming a certified partner.

This isn’t an overnight change. Already manufacturers are developing handsets to be released not just in the coming months, but next year and beyond. Which is all the more reason that Google needs to step up and take responsibility by mandating the positioning in future handset versions and offering the incentive of a robust accessory market to accompany their platform. Because if they don’t, regardless of the number of software advantages Google holds over Apple, Cupertino will always be able to drop the Accessory-bomb on them.

Discuss

(27 Comments)
  • [–]

    Ozbastion

    Thursday, March 24, 2011 at 5:57 PM

    While you’re at it, why not make them all have the same AC/power adapter so consumers only need ONE power charger which is universal across all Android phones?

    • [–]

      jarrard

      Friday, March 25, 2011 at 10:37 AM

      ummm, they are?

      all new models have to be micro usb, and the AC adaptors are just a usb plug, so the cord plugs into all.

  • [–]

    edward co

    Thursday, March 24, 2011 at 6:46 PM

    +1.
    I said something in a similar vein a year ago (i.e. google sould standardise using apple’s connector so they can use all those existing peripherals) and got well flamed; but whatever standard (and microusb is fine, lightpeak/thunderbolt is fine, apple is fine) needs to be really standard across all handsets and tablets for the peripherals market to boom. Otherwise I’m stuck with Apple who get it.

  • [–]

    Glenn

    Thursday, March 24, 2011 at 7:01 PM

    Actually you wouldn’t even have to mandate the exact position of the Micro-USB port, just mandate that the left edge of the Micro-USB must be between say 1cm and 4cm of the left-hand edge, the max thickness of the device, and make the max width accommodate a reasonable landscape device plus about 3cm.

    (These are numbers pulled out of my head just to illustrate the point, obviously there’ll be a lot more thought put into the final dimensions.)

    The insert molds would then be able to match almost any phone on the market today.

    That leaves the device manufactures lots of wriggle room to design the device however they like.

    They could also have a few different classes for the accessory makers with certain dimension, eg. 2-5″ screen devices, 6-8″ screen devices, 9-11″ screen devices etc. That way the accessory maker can decide what their target market is.

  • [–]

    Joe

    Thursday, March 24, 2011 at 7:35 PM

    Not even google how bout single manufacturers when they go from one model to the next. Two years and three work blackberrys. Three different charges, three different USB cables. Wake up manufacturers, I’m not buying extra accessories, I’m just filling my draw full of crap.

  • [–]

    Daniel T

    Thursday, March 24, 2011 at 7:50 PM

    Excellent point Nick, well said.

  • [–]

    abraham

    Thursday, March 24, 2011 at 8:27 PM

    This is a great idea. The only problem is that it does give less competitive edge to each manufacturer since every phone is going to be the same.

    But i would love to buy a cheap gps docking station on my phone and work with other phones!!!

  • [–]

    Sam Cook

    Thursday, March 24, 2011 at 8:32 PM

    Someone mail this article to Google now! I’ve been thinking and wishing for this to happen ever since I got my Android phone, and is my one regret for picking Android over iPhone.

  • [–]

    trk

    Thursday, March 24, 2011 at 9:17 PM

    I disagree.

    I want my choice of handset from a wide variety of options. I much prefer this, to the ability to stick my phone in a clock radio.

    If I wanted a small choice of practically identical handsets, I’d choose a WP7 device. If I wanted an even smaller choice (… of 1), I’d buy an iPhone.

    Besides, docking is so yesterday. It should all be about wifi streaming and induction charging anyway ;)

    The standardising of MicroUSB is great. The standardising of its positioning, and then limiting the physical dimensions of the device? Thats not great. Devices like the Echo couldnt exist in this world, nor the Flipout, nor the playstation phone (whatever it is they’ve decided to call it), nor most with physical keyboards.

    • [–]

      UKROB

      Sunday, September 18, 2011 at 8:29 AM

      I agree with what trk wrote, that it should be wireless streaming of music to docks etc now anyways, however charging at the same time then wouldn’t be as convenient..
      Enforcing a manufacturing rule, that all the micro-USB ports, must be center and bottom of the phone wouldn’t be hard for the manufacturers to abide by at all, therefore i think they should do it anyways.
      In the mean time the creators of speaker docks should be looking forth to implementing wireless music streaming technology, which has already hit the market, but needs to become more widespread = problem solved for Android, which in my opinion is the leading Smartphone OS now and onwards by the looks for things.

  • [–]

    Andy

    Thursday, March 24, 2011 at 9:20 PM

    Restricting hardware design options (which is a key advantage) for accessories?? Jeez

    There will be more than accessory options for every phone version

  • [–]

    Chad

    Thursday, March 24, 2011 at 10:29 PM

    Excellent post. Glad someone out there’s thinking! :)

  • [–]

    Andrew

    Thursday, March 24, 2011 at 10:43 PM

    Oh Nick,.. *facepalm* Do you really want to take a hammer to the face of creativity, innovation and evolution? ..And you of all people, shouldn’t you want new and interesting devices breaking traditional paradigms and redefining how we think about things?? So what if there isn’t a standard dock for it.

    The world of gadgets is exciting because in part a new idea can emerge that doesn’t fit the mould. I wouldn’t want it any other way, and El Goog may even agree with this.

    If the whole world were like Apple, then the world would be a shit place to be. Take your boring keyboardless, game control-less, proprietarily ‘standardized’ tiny screened phone with an out dated UI and stick it in yer dock.

  • [–]

    Caesarus7

    Thursday, March 24, 2011 at 11:34 PM

    this is a good idea and deffinately agree. they could even standardise the 3.5″ jack to support hands free and forward backward and play buttons on the remote of the headphones.

  • [–]

    Travis New

    Thursday, March 24, 2011 at 11:51 PM

    Windows Phone 7 should also figure out where they want to place their connector.

  • [–]

    Scott Bowerman

    Friday, March 25, 2011 at 1:20 AM

    I would love it to be that easy. Being an android user myself I want nothing more than a few great accessories. However, it seems at this stage the micro-usb connection isn’t able to send music out to a dock the same way as apples 30-pin connector. So until this is fixed, no speakers for us….

    • [–]

      Blake

      Tuesday, April 5, 2011 at 5:59 PM

      Two words:
      Headphone jack.

  • [–]

    Sodiq Awokoya

    Friday, March 25, 2011 at 1:27 AM

    You are thinking old school, Keep in mind Android is open source. Google does it for free, they give you a choice to either buy their own Nexus device or the many types of skinned Android thats on the market. Google can’t force hardware changes at all to manufactures when it comes the positing of the ports some Android phones have ports on the landscape side, charging it portrait won’t be possible.

    Google should do, is have manufactures get together and use inductive charging through the back of the phones and With Google the front runner in NFC technology in America you can transmit data. That transmission of data can be music. Google will tell manufactures to use NFC technology.

    so imagine that you have a speaker dock with a flat surface, it can both charge the phone through induction and as well plays songs from, this will make the process way more conducive and allow it to be universal.

    Stop thinking like an average consumer, and think like the developer who can actually change the way we use technology….wireless technology at that.

  • [–]

    Sarah Paul

    Friday, March 25, 2011 at 1:56 AM

    been thinking this for a long time!

  • [–]

    Lasty

    Friday, March 25, 2011 at 10:06 AM

    Rather than dictate how a product should be standardised, I think Sodiq had a good idea. Think OUTSIDE the square people!!

    Maybe NFC Technology is the way to go?

    Or maybe an accessory/dock manufacturers (come on pioneer/jbl/logitech!!) can accomodate for a MAJORITY of the android market whilst still moving towards ideas like NFC. Say a universal stand that has a sliding (repositionable) microUSB connection?

    Considering the beauty of open source, maybe accompany these products with a downloadable (compatable) app that allows music streaming with all the fluff we get with i-products these days (seemless playback, music control protocols, etc etc)

    Few ideas amongst many. Although I think there is a world of opportunity to accomodate for android products, without having to lead towards *grimace* heavily standardising an industry.

  • [–]

    Alex

    Friday, March 25, 2011 at 10:06 AM

    I could not agree more. This is an excellent suggestion, I want better accessories!

  • [–]

    jarrard

    Friday, March 25, 2011 at 10:38 AM

    i never understood why accessories, instead of docking, dont just have a grip handle and a plug like they used to for the old nokia car chargers in the 5110 days etc.

  • [–]

    Greg

    Friday, March 25, 2011 at 3:12 PM

    You can do everything wirelessly on Android, anyway.

    The only reason the Apple Dock still exists is because Apple are stuck in the 20th century where they think cables are necessary to do anything useful.

  • [–]

    PHuZZy

    Friday, March 25, 2011 at 4:00 PM

    rather have induction charge and bluetooth steaming thanks and WP7s.

  • [–]

    Italo

    Thursday, May 12, 2011 at 9:16 PM

    I’m no geek but I couldn’t agree more with this topic. Apart from some sort of standardisation of microUSB, there should be a standardisation of the software (or third party app) that communicates between the dock and the phone. Example the ability for album art, list of tracks, etc to show up on the docks remote display screen. In another scenario, although no dock required, car manufactures can have a standard controler built into car stereos. So tracks, albums, playlists, etc can be selected from the stereo’s screen.

    I have a HTC Desire and it seams like I cannot charge the phone and sync or use as disk drive at the same time. Is this the case with iPhones? If there was some standard of Android dock it should be able to charge at the same time. One reason why dock would be better than wireless.

    • [–]

      Hari

      Thursday, September 1, 2011 at 6:06 PM

      Italo, When you use your phone as a disk drive you are always charging it by default.

      One more thing the beauty of Android is that you don’t need to use it as a disk drive, if you have a wifi network that the phone is connected , you can use an APP like SwiFTP and have the phone (SD Card + Phone ) always explorable and available, No need of messing with cables.

      I use cables only for charging, Data is all over FTP.

  • [–]

    Greg

    Sunday, September 4, 2011 at 5:33 PM

    i want to be able to plug my phone into a dock, and have it charged while playing music in my car or through my stereo, i also want a remote that will control my phone, all these things are capable on an iphone because they have a standard connection.
    i can do all this now, by pluging in a 3.5mm plug, and pluging in a charger, but it is messy, and you have cables running everywere.
    Samsungs new Galaxy S II has a dock that works great, but we need more options.

    so come on anufacturers get you S-^t together.

Join The Discussion