Simon Cowell’s UK Singing Contest Winner: Auto-Tune!

If you’re not familiar with the UK talent show The X Factor, think of it as American Idol with adorable British accents. And also contestants – like Gamu Nhengu here – who never miss note, thanks to glorious Auto-Tuning. Hit it, Gamu!

Nhengu’s recent supplemented audition created a row in the UK, where fans and critics of the show alike were shocked – shocked – to find out that their favourite performers weren’t coming through au naturel. The timing’s also particularly inconvenient for Cowell, who plans to bring X Factor to the US next year.

A few things here. First, yeah, that’s pretty blatant. And heaven forbid the sanctity of a puffed up talent show be violated by some audio wizardry. But in some ways, isn’t this just preparing the contestants for what life’s really like as a singing celebrity? Auto-tune isn’t just for T-Pain – you’d be hard-pressed to find a professional singer who hasn’t employed it in some capacity, at some point or another.

Yes, they should have disclosed they were using Auto-Tune. And yes, the validity of past winners comes into question (except Leona Lewis!). But at least it’s out in the open what the X-Factor is that helps you get and stay famous: technology. [Wired]

Discuss

(4 Comments)
  • [–]

    Luke Colenso Brunsmann

    Wednesday, August 25, 2010 at 1:56 PM

    Better sounds come out of my ass! lol.. Sounds bad even with auto-tune

  • [–]

    AudioGeek

    Wednesday, August 25, 2010 at 5:08 PM

    As an audio professional working in this industry there is no way that would get out of the door without it either being intentional for publicity or the audio exec was getting his own back after being given the boot.

  • [–]

    Samuel Michael Oakmore

    Wednesday, August 25, 2010 at 8:39 PM

    Most “professional” singers listen to their performance after recording it, and when they hear a pitch discrepancy they do not say to the engineer ‘fix it’.

    Most “professional” singers would say “let’s do that again” and it’s my opinion that auto-tune is bullshit. If you need to use more than a subtle pitch shift here and there you don’t have a professional singer.

    I’m not saying everyone has to be a perfect singer, just that singers shouldn’t lie to their audience and hope that their thin facade passes for a performance.

  • [–]

    Gorhob Perkins

    Wednesday, August 25, 2010 at 9:46 PM

    How could you -not- realise that shit was auto-tuned, sounded very obvious. (and awful)

Join The Discussion