I’ve been in a long-term relationship with the iPhone since well before the iPhone 3G launched in 2008. From that very first Jobs keynote, I’ve been captivated by the stunning design and intuitive user interface, the diverse functionality and the convenience of the iPhone. But now, as I approach the end of my 24-month iPhone 3G contract, I’m discovering that the passion has died, and it’s time to move on. iPhone 3G, I think I’m leaving you.
Its not a decision I’ve taken lightly. For a good 18 months, our relationship was as steady as rock set in concrete and reinforced with steel. Other smartphones came and went, but nothing had the power to make me even consider upgrading. Even last year’s 3GS model couldn’t entice me away with its larger storage capacity and faster speeds.
But now things are different. The 3G just isn’t the phone I fell in love with all those years ago.
It’s impossible for me to pinpoint the exact moment my feelings started to change, but I remember little things starting to go wrong about six months ago. Like the album art on my music never being correct, and the phone slowing down while launching a game of Angry Birds. Activities that used to be lightning fast started taking a lot longer. On a number of occasions, the phone would tell me I had no service at all, but after restarting it would show full bars. Syncing started taking longer and longer, despite me adding less and less to the 16GB of storage.
But the knife that severed our relationship was iOS 4.
Ever since upgrading to the new OS – which took me a day and a half and involved a factory reset of the phone to even work – my passion has completely evaporated. With the latest firmware, even the process of unlocking the phone can take seconds. Launching the SMS app to send a text freezes the phone. Typing a message takes an age. I haven’t played a game on the 3G for six weeks – anything with solitaire-level graphics or above is like wrenching up the handbrake in your car while driving along a motorway. Music playback starts jumping like a scratched LP if the phone is ever doing anything else at the same time.The list of niggles and disappointments grows with every passing day, to the point where I now have to say enough is enough.
We had some good times, iPhone 3G. Some great times. But now we’ve grown apart and the love is gone – It’s time for me to move on. Perhaps I’ll spend some time on my own, trying out new handsets each day while I try and forget about you. It’s not like I’m ever wanting for phones to play with.
Maybe I’ll get myself a shiny new iPhone 4, although the likelihood of that happening diminishes every day that Apple deny the reception issue and fail to act on it. Or maybe I’ll just find myself a nice little Android powered handset that doesn’t ask too much of me and has the specs to last me a couple of years.
Whatever happens though, you’ll always be the first smartphone I truly loved using, iPhone 3G. And for that, I will always remember you fondly, regardless of how our relationship ended. Maybe one day in the future, I’ll pull you out of storage and reminisce about the good times we had. But until then, I think it’s better if we don’t speak to each other any more.
Goodbye.




















RawPrawn
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 1:33 PMMy 3G has slowed down considerably with OS4, nothing like what you have experienced though. Games work fine etc.
In response to the iPhone 4 reception issue, here is a great Australian article which has a hands on practical review of the reception. Well worth a read.
http://www.eddale.co/general/on-reception-the-iphone-4-hysteria-the-real-lifelab-test-conundrum
StevoTheDevo
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:53 PMInteresting read, as are the comments…
I wonder if this is one of those circumstances where people’s skin type is making a big difference ?
Seems odd that some can apply the “death grip” with no effect yet another can merely tough the antenna band (but not short 2 antennas) and lose all signal.
bub218
Saturday, October 9, 2010 at 4:46 PMwow all those comments have just done my head in. am so close to diching my nokia for the iphone but not so sure now, everyone who has the i3 just rave about it, so i must have one, now thinking should I. help.
lushr
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 1:37 PMditto.
thought i was never foolish enough to move to iOS4, the slowness, the reception/restart issues, then this lying and carrying on with the iPhone 4…. I’ve really lost my passion.
I’m not willing to go android yet, not until they can make music apps as advanced as iPhone can.
But I’m not willing to go iPhone until they atleast install a digital radio.
It’s that limbo period, like it was before I found the iPhone when there ws nothign on the market that suited ME. How long will I have to wait this time?
Luke
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 1:41 PMWow it’s like you’re reading my mind, the exact same issues are making me think of other phones too.
Glenn Fairbairn
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 1:47 PMDoes the latest iOS4 update fix the speed issues in the 3g?
Lamul
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 1:48 PMWhat bothers me is that the iPhone couldnt remain reliable over a standard 24 month contract!
Worrying for a potential first iPhone buyer like me.
JonBOY26
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 1:49 PMthis is an interesting read. My girlfriend has an iPhone 3G and compared to my 3GS it’s performance is horrific. She recently updated to iOS 4 and has encountered many of the same problems/results.
-unlocking the phone takes ages, ie following the finger swipe the screen just does not respond for 2 – 3 seconds or so
-launching messages takes FOREVER!!!!
-the iOS 4 update took half a day!
-the iOS 4 update deleted ALL of her photos! (she’s fuming over that!!!)
-the iOS 4 update deleted SOME of her contacts (it’s weird that only some were deleted…even so, she’s fuming over that too!)
-the user interface is slow and lags behind user input
I have no issues with iOS 4 on my 3GS, however the girlfriend is adamant that she wants to go back to 3.1.3…….is reverting to 3.1.3 even possible?
Seamus Byrne
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:21 PMLifehacker had a story on the revert process:
http://www.lifehacker.com.au/2010/06/how-to-downgrade-from-ios-4-to-iphone-3-1-3/
Jon Underwood
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 5:24 PMas long as you read the various instructions well enough, its a straight forward process. 4.0 is such a dog on the 3g, but once i went back to 3.1.2, much better. plus with a few jailbreak apps (irealsms, activator, sbsettings etc), its a far more useable phone than the vanilla 3g ever was.
my next phone will not be an iphone though – possibly some kind of android, but still researching that.
Matt Stone
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 1:52 PMLets just hope all us Aussie 3G users will get our hands on shiny new FIXED iphone 4′s and have the first love experience once again…. here’s to hoping… and waiting till tm morning!
Ana
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 1:53 PMAhhh same here..
Contracts coming up, 3g is running so slow it hurts..
That and the screen is cracked
got all excited my contract runs out in time for iPhone 4 and now I’m not so sure??
Don’t think I’m ready to jump to android??
Ahh don’t know what to do? Painful innit
First world problems hey?
boc
Monday, July 19, 2010 at 2:05 AMI bit the bullet and went Android and am happy.
If you can’t bring yourself to do the same then why not get an iPhone 3GS?
It’s an incremental upgrade but, it’s safe and familiar and when the iPhone 4 comes out the 3GS should be dirt cheap.
matt
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 1:58 PMlol, ironically, when it comes to dumping real girls, we just do it over twitter… facebook status update…
Jamie Carl
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 1:59 PMYou guys are like 18 months behind the rest of the world. Ditch your iPhones and get a nice HTC Android phone.
The iPhone is dead.
Bernhard de Kok
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:30 PMWhat alternative timeline are you living in? Android is only just now worth looking at. 12 to 18 months ago, all versions of Android were seriously lacking as was its App store.
And the US is definately NOT the rest of the world, which is where Android phones are popular (especially 18 months ago).
Pranoy Ghosh
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 3:16 PMYou are so right..Australia is quite hunter-gatherer in terms of technology and I just got my HTC Desire and its a great replacement for the iPhone
geoff
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:01 PMIOS4.1 fixes the slowness issues: released to beta this week.
Simon Reidy
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:05 PMI too am nearing the end of a two year love affair with my 3G and I have to agree that iOS4 has been nothing but a nightmare for our relationship.
I even made the mistake of jailbreaking my 3G on iOS4 and attempted to add multitasking, wallpaper, Lockinfo, QuickReply, SBSettings and Backgrounder. Now it just feels like the norm waiting 5 seconds for my phone to unlock, or having apps crash back to the springboard every few seconds. I’m constantly going into sbsettings, closing apps and running the free memory command to try and squeeze an extra 2 MBs out of the OS so I can check my email without a one second lag between every key press. iOS4 was never designed to run with 128MB ram and it shows.
At this point it kind feels like a relationship where I’m cheating by looking at other handsets longingly, but I haven’t gone as far as play around with other models yet (playing around with models..mmmm)…
As much as I hate Apple’s secret, closed off businesses practices, and the ridiculous wall of silence surrounding the clearly broken antenna, I think I will probably still stick with iPhone. My current model has simply got old and wrinkly and I need something that does what I want it to while looking young and hot. iPhone 4 I’m looking at you.
The closest I’ve come to signing the divorce papers with my iphone was when Optus offered up the Galaxy S. I love that 4″ SAMOLED screen and the speedy hummingbird processor, but Android still doesn’t offer everything I want, the market is clumsy and incomplete, and the camera, video quality and battery life just aren’t quite there.
If Apple comes clean, accepts responsibility for the faulty antenna design, and does more than offer customers a free bumper case, I’m going to take the plunge and buy an iPhone 4. I know it’s far from perfect but it really does offer nearly everything I’m after in a smartphone. Once jailbroken it will be a force to be reckoned with.
Nowdays trying to argue my preference to stick with Apple to Android fans is like trying to defend Windows 7 to a Linux fanboy. They HATE Apple with a passion that resembles a crazed soccer fan, and deep down you know what they are saying is ultimately right. However you’d rather a pretty dumbed down OS that you know and love rather than a more powerful, but cumbersome and unstable beta build of an OS that will one day be great.
Now hurry up Jobs and run your company properly, so I can buy an iPhone 4 before I change my mind.
Brett
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:07 PMWell said, my thoughts exactly. Had a fight with mine yesterday when trying to use google maps, nearly ended with me introducing it to concrete.
Think it was mad about my incoming Nexus…
Goodbye Iphone, thanks for the memories :)
mickk
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:12 PMsniff, iPhone 3G just wasn’t giving back towards the end there.
little bitch.
PhuzZy
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:13 PMDon’t forget.. you could wait a little bit and get a nice Windows Phone 7 device.
Paul McManus
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:22 PMNah, wait for the first service pack.
Raffi
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:17 PMA lot of my friends swore by the iphone 3G and 3Gs. That’s until they played with my HTC Desire for a few minutes. Android is OPEN. And runs on better hardware. I can have over 10 apps running at the same time and the phone is as responsive as it was the second I took it out of the box. in the 3-4 months I’ve had it, I’ve only had to reset it once.
Ditch the apple pieces of junk and get an android…
Arfur Sixpence
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 4:51 PMOkay Raffi, how long are you getting between charges? Be honest now…
David
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:18 PMEver since moving to iOS4 on my iPhone 3GS my phone is unusable. My list of complaints grows every few hours as I try and figure out exactly what Apple broke.
Here are a few of the bugs that really irk me.
- The phone doesn’t sync unless I use the ‘Restore’ Option. This is not a once off, this literally happens every time I want to sync my phone, Its gotten to the point where I don’t do it anymore
- I cant play half the video podcasts I sync’d to my phone. This number grows each day, I have over 2 dozen on my phone and I can currently play 10, the others just error out
- The phone bugs out to the point where I have to restart it because it wont open an app (including the phone)
- Dropped calls because the phone app bugs out. Failed messages because the message app bugs out and missed emails because the email app bugs out
- My phone stops getting data. If I’m using an app (lets say, safari or digg) I will open the app and start browsing, after a page or 2 loads, the app stops using data, 3g or wifi, The connection is there but the phone will not load anything. I have to restart my phone in order to get it to work again.
I now understand why apple fanboys always update their stuff. Apple cripples it your stuff if you don’t. I have never come across such a bug addled device (And I used symbian OS for 5 years)
But seriously, anyone know of a good Android phone?
Arfur Sixpence
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 4:55 PMNo, David. An Android phone with a decent functioning battery does not exist at present. HTC is only too happy, however, to sell you a phone with battery out of the middle ages. Why they call them ‘mobile’ phones when they are virtually tied to their chargers is beyond me.
Des
Saturday, July 17, 2010 at 7:07 AMI don’t know about that. My Nexus One lasts for a couple of days without charge with ease.
Luke
Thursday, July 22, 2010 at 11:23 AMArfur, that hasn’t been my experience with Android either. I can easily make it through a day without charging my HTC, no matter the activity (e.g. wifi browsing, gaming etc.)
Android phones also charge over a mini-USB cable, no proprietary connectors there :) The phones charge quickly too (30 minutes and you’re good for the rest of the day).
Granted, I’d pack a charger for a weekend away though.
Keith Drain
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:20 PMNick,
Thats fine for you man, you get given handsets all the time to try out. I can’t get a new phone without spending big $ on it or signing another 2 year contract. I want an iPhone 4 but it will be delayed. Downgrading to 3.1.3 is a PITA and I’m still stuck with a slow ass iPhone 3G with 4.0. Why the hell would they release 4.0 on hardware that barely runs it. It does nothing different other than folders and unified inbox both of which I could live without if I could downgrade and keep my data.
What are we supposed to do? Just put up with this crap until the iPhone 4 eventually gets here? I’ve invested heavily in Apps so I don’t even know if switching to an Android phone is an option!
kris
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:21 PMHAHA! I don’t own an iphone, and after reading this article, i never will! They just plain suck!
Arfur Sixpence
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 5:00 PMMy wife loves her 3GS. It does everything she needs it for; it works as a telephone (most of the time), as a messaging device and takes the odd half decent photo. I’m thrilled too because I got her barely used F480 as my Motorola had died after 4 years of trusty service.
Bernhard de Kok
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:37 PMI’ve loved my 3G, which was clearly the best phone at the time (2 years ago), but it’s incredibly tired now because of that iOS4 upgrade. I’ve kept my wifes 3G at 3.1.3 and the difference is very noticeable. I’ll have to replace mine.
I looked at Android, its interesting, but useability is more important to me than specs and I’m not about to drop the massive investment in apps that I’ve purchased from the App store. Tom Tom, by itself was $99.00, so I’ll wait for the iPhone 4. I’m not concerned about the sensitive spot on the lower left as I never touch that area anyway, but it’s a moot point as I always use a case. It’s too big an investment to leave it naked.
Raffi
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:59 PMYou get google maps for free on android!
Arfur Sixpence
Sunday, July 18, 2010 at 2:40 PMRaffi, you didn’t answer my question above…
Daniel
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:53 PMSold my iPhone 3G on eBay for $500 and never looked back. This was just a month ago too.
Resale is high.
Ben
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 2:59 PMI have a 3G with iOS4, jailbroken with multitasking enabled.
The phone is perfectly responsive, with only one app running, or just iPod and Messages.
But once I’ve put half a dozen apps into the background the performance is rubbish, just like you have described in your article.
So I contend that multitasking is enabled even if you haven’t jailbroken – you just can’t double-click to bring up the list of running apps.
What do you reckon folks?
normandy
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 3:10 PMtry ios 4.01 it made my iphone 3g fast again!
NickT
Saturday, July 17, 2010 at 12:47 PM+1
I had the slow down mentioned, but the install was painless. Anyhow 4.01 seems to have made it speedy again :)
Quasio
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 3:10 PMExactly same thought.. i use to love this phone, 3GS didn’t appeal coz the 3G was “good enough”.
but with each new software release they increase the artificial wait loop of a 3G. making it slower more hesitant..
if (iphone == 3G)
wait(100secs) //marketing dept: please increase timer on each software update!
in the end with no massive feature increase, why the slowdown? of course.. to make u buy a new phone.. this will happen with the 3GS, will happen with the iphone 4, that’s how apple marketing works.. bring in features slowly enough to ensure u _HAVE_ to buy the new phone.
off to android this time.
matt
Saturday, July 17, 2010 at 7:08 AMI think you will find that function to be:
wait(number_of_generations_out_of_date * 100sec);
if(launch_of_new_device_imminent)
wait(2000sec);
Labrat
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 3:16 PMmy 3gs rocks on iOS4..
No thoughts of a WinPhone7?
TrickiDicki
Friday, July 16, 2010 at 6:03 PMMy 3G is much happier now that I did a Restore – the upgrade totally borked. There are a couple of apps that are sluggish, the calendar being the worst offender. Very frustrating when trying to whip the old fella out to see what you’re supposed to be doing, only to be confronted with a pause *whur* blank *whur* *whur* calendar.
Overall, 3.x was better, ios4 is manageable.