
In writing an exposé on Apple’s supply chain, Reuters’ reporters fleshed out what we already know: There’s an immense pressure on companies under contract with Apple not to leak any information about forthcoming products; said companies have shady labour histories; working for one of these companies frankly sounds terrifying.
We touched on these problems when Foxconn was accused of driving an employee to suicide over an iPhone prototype leak last year, but at the time, our picture of Foxconn was patched together from a pile of second and third-hand reports, conflicting local news stories and PR spin. To date, there hasn’t been a better illustration of the problem than this:
Tipped by a worker outside the Longhua complex that a nearby Foxconn plant was manufacturing parts for Apple too, our correspondent hopped in a taxi for a visit to the facility in Guanlan, which makes products for a range of companies.
As he stood on the public road taking photos of the front gate and security checkpoint, a guard shouted. The reporter continued snapping photos before jumping into a waiting taxi. The guard blocked the vehicle and ordered the driver to stop, threatening to strip him of his taxi licence.
The correspondent got out and insisted he was within his rights as he was on the main road. The guard grabbed his arm. A second guard ran over, and with a crowd of Foxconn workers watching, they tried dragging him into the factory.
The reporter asked to be let go. When that didn’t happen, he jerked himself free and started walking off. The older guard kicked him in the leg, while the second threatened to hit him again if he moved. A few minutes later, a Foxconn security car came along but the reporter refused to board it. He called the police instead.
After the authorities arrived and mediated, the guards apologized and the matter was settled. The reporter left without filing a complaint, though the police gave him the option of doing so.
“You’re free to do what you want,” the policeman explained, “But this is Foxconn and they have a special status here. Please understand.”
So, let’s get this straight: If you, a reporter, take pictures of the outside of a Foxconn factory, you can dragged, kicked, threatened and reminded of how ominously “special” Foxconn’s relationship with Apple makes them. (PS: Omigod, have you heard about the new iPad!?)
For Apple, this could mean two things: That they long ago entered into business with a company that’s predisposed to violent enforcement of company policy; or that their extreme demands for secrecy, and extreme value to Foxconn, have driven the company to become this way.
In neither situation is Apple the culprit. In both, though, they’re totally – and worryingly – complicit. [Reuters via Business Insider]


















Hiro
Thursday, February 18, 2010 at 10:57 AMAre you so blind to think that this world revolves on whats right and wrong ?
In places like china where there is little value on the human life and even less value on the rights of said human life. This reporter should be thankful he wasn’t shot.
boc
Thursday, February 18, 2010 at 12:39 PMAnd that’s the way Apple likes it. LOL
Seriously though, Hiro is correct. Maybe decades or centuries from now China will pull itself out of it’s pseudo 3rd world/developing nation status and actually consider the rights of the people and not just the rights of the people with money.
ThePengwin
Thursday, February 18, 2010 at 12:53 PM“The reporter asked to be let go”
Something tells me that “asked” is not the best descriptive word there.
I think both parties are in the wrong. The security guards were out of line, but a reporter takng photos of foxconn sounds a bit like poking a bear with a stick.
simulacrum
Thursday, February 18, 2010 at 4:00 PMIt’s the reporter’s job to poke bears with sticks. And as long as he is within his legal rights he is simply fulfilling his duty as a journalist and is certainly not “in the wrong”. The security guards clearly violated the law and are completely in the wrong. If bears aren’t occasionally poked they could turn into dragons.
Bernie
Thursday, February 18, 2010 at 1:32 PMIt’s a difficult situation for both sides (Foxconn and the reporter), but the parallels can be found in other situations.
If a reporter stands outside a sensitive military base in the USA and takes some pictures of the base, how do you think the military gaurds will react? Sure a different emphasis on what you think is important, but the result is the same. The reporter has technically done nothing wrong, but it might be the last time you see them.
Strange world…
tsengan
Friday, February 19, 2010 at 8:26 AMAnd not just military bases. I can think of a few megacorporations who would react pretty similarly, no matter which country they are in.
Kicking the reporter in the shin, though? That’s pure China. Go China.
Joe
Thursday, February 18, 2010 at 1:33 PMHi, Foxconn is a Taiwanese companies.
adelaide dancing
Thursday, February 18, 2010 at 3:31 PMwow, sounds like something straight out of star wars haha
Paul Cherry
Friday, February 19, 2010 at 12:27 AM*Insert Sarcasm* – I highly doubt Apple make this company very rich, and in turn, they make the guards and police “rich” among poor, you would probably do the same if defending same.
Sounds like an awesome idea for a new TV series. Get Michael Scofield on board to break in to and back out of “The Company” with the latest prototype.