Regulars

Living With: The MacBook Air

Posted by Nick Broughall at 9:55 AM on May 27, 2008
air.jpg
Say hello to the first in a new series of quasi-regular reviews from Giz AU: we like to call it, "Living With".

Because, put simply, most reviews you get out there on the interwebs have come from the reviewer using a device for a few hours, maybe a couple of days before they pen their thoughts. And when it comes to gadgets, sometimes you need a bit longer to really come to grips with all the cool features, pesky bugs or even the whole purpose of the device in the first place.

And seeing as how I've been playing around with the MacBook Air for a couple of weeks now, I thought it would be a great place to start. Hopefully it will help you decide whether the MacBook Air is the notebook for you:

 


As I mentioned before, I've been playing with the SSD version of the MacBook Air for a couple of weeks. And despite the fact part of me was hoping that my review unit would be delivered in a paper envelope, it came in packaging that was only slightly less attractive than the Air itself, which is saying a lot. When I pulled the Air from its box hand held it up for my wife to see, her response was short and to the point: "wow".

Powering up the Air for the first time I was quick to notice that it isn't the fastest machine to boot up. It takes about four seconds before you hear Apple's customary power chime, then another 55 seconds before you can login. The same goes for shutting down - you can be waiting for a full minute for the Air to do what it has to do before it's off. Fortunately, I discovered that the Air is very efficient on battery life when in sleep mode, and waking from sleep is pretty much instantaneous (although it does take a little bit to connect to your wireless networks), so just shutting the laptop is definitely the way to go.

The build-quality of the Air is fantastic. I was carrying this thing around by the screen, by the corner, by the keyboard, and it didn't feel compromised in any way. There was no fear of ruining my data either considering I was using the SSD model, although if I were to buy one of these, I'd probably opt for the hard drive option - the premium on the SSD isn't justifiable.
The keyboard is the same as my iMac (and the MacBook), so it was a familiar and comfortable experience.

One of the first things I tested after pulling out the Air was the transferring of data wirelessly between it and my iMac. Considering there's no DVD drive, this is the only way you can install software on your machine (unless you download it from the web). The process itself is fairly simple, but it isn't exactly quick. And you have to be selective about what you actually put on your Air - 64GB (or 80GB for the HDD version) isn't a lot of space. My music and photos stayed on my iMac, but by turning on sharing I was able to access them over the network anyway when I was around the house. You can't playback a DVD or CD using the remote drive option, but I didn't really want to do that anyway. Did you?

Over the course of the past two weeks, I haven't missed the optical drive once. I haven't missed an ethernet port or having more than one USB port either. That's probably just how I've been using the device, and may be different for other people, but I barely noticed at all. And despite reports of the USB slot being too small, all of the thumb drives I've stuck in there have worked perfectly. I'm still waiting to test out 3's new wireless internet stick though.

If there is one area that really does make me sit back and pause in my recommendation of the Air it is the mobile Internet situation. It would have been easy for Apple to add a SIM card slot to the Air's body. Instead, you're either restricted to having no internet when you're out and about, using a USB dongle device (which are ugly and cumbersome), pairing with a 3G phone over Bluetooth, or risking the possibility that the USB stick wireless modem won't fit in the USB slot. In any case, having an internet card sticking out the side makes the Air harder to fit into bags, and does detract from its visual appeal.

Battery life is pretty good, especially if you remember to switch of Airport when you're not connected to the web. Its lasted me four hours without Airport switched on (the time it takes me to catch the train to the city and back). Another brilliant inclusion is two plugs for the charger - one that plugs the transformer straight into the wall and one that adds a couple of metres of cable.

So, what's the verdict? The more I use the Air, the more I need to own it. This laptop isn't for everyone - if you use your laptop as your main computer, for example, you'll probably miss the features like a DVD drive or an ethernet port. But if you have a desktop and need a laptop to compliment it when your out on the road (blogging from events, for example), then this is a superior piece of kit.

Still, I'm not going to buy one just yet. For a start they're too expensive (it's only $200 less than a MacBook Pro, yet has less features), and I have a feeling that the next generation may just include that SIM card slot - I have no evidence to back that up, before you ask. So despite my lust, the common sense side of my brain is keeping my wallet closed - for the time being, at least.

If you have any questions or would like me to qualify any points, feel free to let me know in comments!

[MacBook Air on Giz]

Comments (AU Comments · US Comments)

Alex

Posted May 27, 2008 11:54 AM

It seems like this is one of the few reviews that is independent from its high cost, do you think the price will come down? it's not like apple to do that, look at the MBP, lol. also, correct me if i'm wrong, but along with a sim card slot woulden't it also need a cellular attena? is there really room for that? they can put the spot in an easy to reach place, behind the battery. (lol)

Flame

Posted May 27, 2008 11:57 AM

Useful info, cheers

Nick Broughall

Posted May 27, 2008 12:38 PM

@Alex - the price will come down eventually. You cite the Macbook Pro, which is their top of the line machine - but look at the Macbook. It was $2,099 for the basic specs at launch - now it starts at $1,499.

You're also right about the antenna. I'm not an engineer, so I have no idea how it could be put in, but hell - they could add a millimetre to the Air and nobody would care if it meant always on internet... I think generally though they're located in the frame of the monitor...

Daniel Ergas

Posted May 27, 2008 3:13 PM

What?!?
As I am typing this on my Macbook Air that I got a month or two ago for me it only takes me 20-30 seconds to shut down and that is with Vista! And I have the base model 2.6ghz and the non SSD. Personally it is great but it is even better with the Telstra Sierra Wireless USB Modem. It is the best! And no I do not work at Telstra. Get your MBA checked out at an Apple Store.

zacislost

Posted May 27, 2008 4:14 PM

Can't wait for a potential Macbook ProAir
I want the thin and light form factor with the guts neeeded to perform complex audiovisual editing

Mr.Pantic

Posted May 27, 2008 5:54 PM

Apple could add a sim card tray, Apple could do this, Apple could do that. True, Apple could add many features and do many things, however, they're keeping in mind that, at the moment, mobile network providers charge an arm and a leg for data. Take Telstra for example, $99.00 for 3gb? Pleaseee... only a dick*@#! would spend that much money to use the internet via a careers overpriced and painfully slow, data service. Internet via wifi/wimax/celular without interruptions, in theory, is great, however, no-one is ready for it until certain w@nkers stop over-charging and under-delivering. I'm certain Apple has 100 x prototypes of tablets, ultrathin pro laptops, pda's etc, but its all about the timing and when certain components become available at reasonable prices.

But having said that... just a reminder...
Apple is King... (but you all knew that anyway)

Pantic - over - n - out

OS11

Posted May 28, 2008 1:51 AM

fine article nick, just wanted to point out that you rarely need to shutdown the Mac or boot it. OSX is based on UNIX, and it is designed to stay on 24/7/365. When you're done using it, simply close the lid when you want to use it again, open the lid.

Sweet!

I think the whole booting up / shutting down routine is a bad habit reinforced from the PC world not the Mac world. Macs have always been much better at sleeping and waking up.

So do yourself a favor and simply sleep or close the lid when you are done, and it will save you a lot of time since it is designed to work that way.

-

Thi.

Posted May 28, 2008 2:21 AM

You write, " Another brilliant inclusion is two plugs for the charger - one that plugs the transformer straight into the wall and one that adds a couple of metres of cable. "

This "feature" comes on all, and I do mean all, Mac laptops. It has been for many years now, even before the MagSafe adaptors were out.

lazydesi

Posted May 28, 2008 8:57 AM

nice review,

can you provide more info on sound? for example I am bored and want to watch some movies during my trip, howz the sound quality?

Stew

Posted May 29, 2008 1:11 PM

I'm holding out for the the Atom-based Eee PC, but then again I'm one of the people who can't live without a few of the things the MBA doesn't have. And I'd still sorely miss an optical drive, even if it's just a reader & not a burner (for travelling, DivXs on DVDs is how I roll, baby).

Post Your Comment

Gizmodo Australia moderates comments to avoid spam and abuse. We're looking for comments that are interesting, substantial and/or highly amusing. HTML is not accepted.

You must supply a name and your email address.