Net Neutrality Shouldn’t Extend to Illegal Acts, Says FCC Comissioner

One of the FCC’s five commissioners, Jonathan Adelstein, said during a recent symposium on FCC Internet Video Policy that the FCC’s rules shouldn’t permit “illegal acts.” Sure, illegal downloading is a serious problem, especially if you’re a copyright-holding movie studio. But does that mean the FCC is actually against net neutrality, in general?

Adelstein half dodged that with a question: “The problem is, how can you ever tell what’s illegal?” Well you can’t, not without some serious filtering and snooping by ISPs, and a lot of wrangling over whether uploading or downloading is deemed piracy. And what about telling the difference between illegally sharing a movie from a big studio, and sharing an independently-produced movie designed for P2P sharing? Clearly, the FCC isn’t comfortable going all in for content filtering, at least not yet.

We’ll just have to watch to see what this implies for the final net neutrality guidelines. [Ars Technica]