Noise-Cancelling Headphones Might Make You Motion Sick

You know those noise-cancelling headphones that make it so you don’t hear engine noise while travelling? Well, they might just make you sick. Really sick. Bad news for Bose!


Check out this Q&A from today’s Wall Street Journal:

Q: I was recently given a pair of the Bose QC3 headphones [smaller earphones at top]with active noise cancelling, and have felt queasy every time I put them on. I had to take them off and lie down at one point, and ended up throwing up later that night and was unable to eat more than apple sauce the next day. As crazy as it sounds, did the headphones cause my discomfort?

A: It’s possible. Bose’s “Acoustic Noise Cancelling” headphones work by electronically determining the difference between wanted and unwanted sounds, and creating a correction signal that acts to negate the unwanted noise, according to its Web site. (The company didn’t respond to requests to comment.) Sarah Stackpole, a New York ear, nose and throat doctor, speculates that the sound waves that cancel each other out may still transmit enough very low frequency vibrations to stimulate the balance receptors that are connected to the hearing hair cells in the inner ear. These vibrations are akin to those caused by blast explosions or barotrauma in scuba diving, but much less forceful, she says. The disequilibrium that some people may feel from this is made worse because the vibrations falsely signal that the head is moving, but the eyes report that the head is stationary. Those mixed signals make the headphone wearer feel dizzy.

Obviously, many people have and use noise-cancelling headphones all the time with no problems, but if you’ve got a sensitive inner-ear, you should be careful before making the plunge. And if you’ve ever felt a little sick after using a pair, now you know why.

Has anyone had similar experiences? [Wall Street Journal via Book of Joe]

Discuss

(11 Comments)
  • [–]

    KRANG

    Wednesday, February 13, 2008 at 5:19 PM

    This comment has been deemed inappropriate and has been deleted

    • [–]

      Feras

      Tuesday, July 6, 2010 at 5:57 PM

      I just bought the Bose QC-3 and feeling Headache everytime I use them. I do Scuba Diving and I felt like there is kind of pressure when wearing them. Sad enough I am disappointed with this side effect and yet not so sure whether this will cause any damage on the long run to my ears or not.

  • [–]

    Rachel

    Thursday, May 7, 2009 at 4:24 AM

    I have a similar problem, but with noise canceling ear buds. They were really cheap, so I doubt I’m experiencing anything so high tech –but I do notice that if I don’t keep one of the ear buds out, I get a terrible headache and feel a little nausea. I actually still get a slight headache with just one in, but it’s bearable…

    @KRANG
    Rude people who make comments like yours don’t necessarily “multiply” either.

  • [–]

    Roman F

    Saturday, December 19, 2009 at 2:20 PM

    I was all geeked about the pricy top end sony and bose noise cancel headsets and was ready to buy….while checking them out at the store, which had display sets hooked up…for about 15-20 minutes….I noticed a low level headache, which persisted thru the evening after i left the store. ….2 weeks later I went to check them out again…same thing. So unfortunatly some of us who have sensitivity will not be able to enjoy these fine items.

  • [–]

    Chad Garber

    Sunday, December 20, 2009 at 5:11 AM

    I was so excited to get these headphones a) b/c they’re Bose&expensive, but b) they were a gift! Unfortunately I’ve had the on for 1 song and my temples are pulsing and my stomach feels queasy. Ive never scuba dove before but it did feel akin to being at the bottom of a deep end of a pool. It’s too bad these don’t work without the noise-cancelling feature ‘always on’.
    Conclusion: someone’s going to get one hell of a regift!

    • [–]

      Georgie

      Monday, November 7, 2011 at 9:25 PM

      Hi chad
      Read yr exp with your Bose headphone how much would u like for them cause im keen to buy them asap thanks
      Georgie

      • [–]

        Wade

        Saturday, November 12, 2011 at 7:38 PM

        Hey Georgie,
        pretty sure Chad may have gotten rid of the headphones by now, his post was two years ago… :)

  • [–]

    Sam Lucas

    Sunday, February 13, 2011 at 4:27 PM

    I fell in love with my QC3s.
    Never felt anything like it.
    It only brings tranquility and
    clear music.

  • [–]

    Stan M.

    Tuesday, July 12, 2011 at 6:28 AM

    i had a friend give me a pair of Maxell’s, I also have a weird feeling when they are turned on, i also have issues watching 3D.

  • [–]

    chocobonight

    Friday, December 16, 2011 at 11:21 PM

    i just baought a pare of head phones with noise cansilation (witch im warign right now) and my temples heurt at some points i have to take them off and lay down but it goes away pritty quick

    but my father baought a pare and now have ringing in his ear that whont stop
    im not sheure if it is the cause but if it is ill have to return them (please excuse my Bad spelling)

  • [–]

    emma c

    Thursday, January 5, 2012 at 3:59 PM

    I use the panasonic rp-hc700 headphones and had been feeling “woozy” for a while and thought i may be getting ill. Just turned off the noise cancelling setting after reading this article…. BINGO! no more woozy!
    To test it I left it turned off for half an hour till i felt fine, turned it back on again and within 5 mins I felt nauseous again. Thank heavens for this article. I was thinking of going to see my doctor about it. lol

Join The Discussion